Public Testimony / PetitionMachelle Hill
From: 4fiddy@q.com
Sent: Monday, July 09, 2012 2:15 PM
To: clerk
Subject: Opposing application PP 12-010 CUP 12-006 Mulberry Sub
Good afternoon,
We are writing to you to express our opposition on the application you have received for the apartments
proposed adjacent to Settler's park. We believe the application number is PP 12-010 CUP 12-006 Mulberry Sub.
Although we understand the need for our local community to have continued growth and how important new
building is to the economy, we can not support the building of apartments that will essentially be located at one
of our most used parks (Settler's Park). Our main points of opposition are:
1. The traffic studies that were discussed during the neighborhood meetings held by Engineering Solutions
referenced studies there were done in 2008 and February 2010. Given that the most recent study occurred in the
middle of winter, we do not feel that the data collected is of any merit and should not be used in the evaluation
of whether or not the current road system would be adversely impacted by this new complex. As you know, this
park has grown in popularity by leaps and bounds since 2008 and therefore we believe that new statistics are
warranted.
2. Potential impact to home values. Although we realize that all Meridian homeowners are in the same situation
with our home values depleting so drastically during the down economy, allowing these apartments to be build
right next a existing subdivision without any requirements of a separate entrance will have a further negative
impact on our homes value.
3. There are already several apartment complexes in the construction phase in this particular area. Although it is
important to ensure that there is the right blend of housing for our communities, it is just as important to
monitor that we do not over build and create an environment where we have more housing than we have tenants
to rent them.
4. General concern of the park atmosphere. Given where the apartments are being proposed to be built with no
distinct divide between them and the park, we feel that cosmetically it is not a good fit. Over the past several
years events in the park have grown considerably. We feel that these apartments may adversely impact future
events, and that is not what we are looking for in our community. Something as simple as "movie in the park"
may be impacted due to the noise level of the movies and the location of the apartments. We realize this is a
very small item in such a large subject, but these types of events in the park are important to the community and
draw families from all over.
We thank you for your consideration of our comments and look forward to attending the various application
meetings.
Mark & Kim Luchs
3742 N. Elsinore Way
Meridian
Machelle Hill
~i-~
From: Jaycee Holman
Sent: Monday, July 02, 2012 8:30 AM
To: Jacy Jones; Machelle Hill; Sonya Wafters; Bill Parsons
Subject: FW: Concerns about Settlers Park,LLC development of the southwest corner of W Ashby and
N Meridian Road (Notice Of Hearing)
I responded and let them know we will make their comments part of the record.
Jaycee L. Holman
City Clerk
City of Meridian
(208)888-4433
jhol ma n(a)meridiancity. org
From: EnJ Smith [mailto:fishermanswife64@msn.com]
Sent: Saturday, June 30, 2012 7:03 PM
To: Jaycee Holman
Subject: RE: Concerns about Settlers Park,LLC development of the southwest corner of W Ashby and N Meridian Road
(Notice Of Hearing)
To Whom It May Concern,
We are sending this written material/concern regarding the Settlers Park LLC development @ the corner of W
Ashby and N Meridian Road. We received the information regarding Notice of Hearing. We have attended all
meetings regarding this property. And will be at the scheduled meeting on July 19,2012. We don't wish to speak
at the meeting. However, we want our concerns addressed and recognized at the meeting and before the
meeting.
Our backyard backs up to the Settler Park LLC development. We are very concerned and upset with the zone
change that is different than the zoning mentioned in our ccr by laws. The medium/high density development
will invade in our privacy greatly. And as existing home owners this is a problem. If we wanted rear
neighbors/2 storey or more behind us we would have purchased a home according. Our rights as an existing
homeowners and tax payer we have the right to keep our privacy. We are very concerned how it will effect our
property value. Living next to any apartment type living will make a huge difference in our property value/
home resale. With the economy the way it is no one can afford to take a bigger hit/loss as we already have. We
are also concerned with Neighborhood safety, traffic, crime and overall security in what comes with apartment
building living. As homeowners that have spent/lost money on a serious water problem due to the type of soil,
improper grading of the land, we are very concerned about the grading, drainage/seepage that this development
may cause on our property. Since spending thousands of dollars to correct our problem back in 2007 we have
not had drainage problems since. We feel with incorrect grading of the development, over water of the
property, seepage drainage, etc. this will make a impact on our property. As property tax payers we are
concerned what this development will do to our beautiful Settlers Park and the safety of all the many decent
families that go there daily. Building apartments basically right on the park is huge problem. Especially if the
apartments do not have a fence, wall etc. built around the property. This can be a huge problem for our
community. Apartment living brings in a different clientele of people and being built on a park this will bring
drugs, alcohol, crime etc to our existing community.
Please take all of our many concerns into consideration. Building multi-family homes in our existing
neighborhood and on a park is just not good. Please don't allow this project to proceed. Please require them to
build something in the line of the current community/neighborhood environment.
Sincerely,
Eric and Joy Smith
3635 N Staunton Pl
Meridian, ID 83646
208-841-5056
Written Testimony against Conditional Use Permit (PP12-010) Settlers Park LLC (AKA Mulberry
Subdivision 36 Unit Aaartment Complez)
Meridian Planning & Zoning Hearing on 7/19/2412 (x,7:00 nm Meridian City Hall
Submitted by: Martin & Mazgo Comorosky (Cedaz Springs HOA Boazd Member) ~~ ~ E I V ED
3804 N. Alexis Way
Meridian, Idaho 83646 J U L 12 2012 ~/~.
We are against the proposed Conditional Use Permit (PP 12-010 Settlers Park LLC) CITY O F GR-fF w..
for the following reason: CITY CLERKS OFFICE
We signed a legal document/contractvith the development owner, H. Bruce Murdock on July 31,
2003 (Subdivision CCRs ,written by Howell-Murdock Development Corporation and signed by
Kevin A Howell (President) dated & notarized 12/10/2002).
In this contract, Page 2, Section 1.3, states that "Phase 4 and possible Phase 5 are intended to be
developed by the Declarant (Development Owner) and may be developed as some form of
commercial office retail or other business related uses. A portion may or may not also be
developed as a school site. "Also "In the event that the school site or the business phases are not
developed f r school and business uses and are developed as single family residential uses, then
the lots therein shall be subiect to these CCRs when and_ if annexed into these CCRs ". The section
sites Exhibit C as reference which is a plot plan and specifically has Phase 4 identified as 61ots
and written as "possible business lots".
We signed off on this contract with the understanding there would possibly be business related
use, if not more single family residential use. Under no circumstances would we have signed this
contract as a home owner, if instead the intent stated by the "Declarant" included multi family
residential use.
Therefore, when the City of Meridian granted the zoning change from R4 to R15 during 2004-
2005 ,the City of Meridian failed to complete the legal land use rezoning process by not
reviewing all legal documents (contracts in place with Owners in Cedar Springs Subdivision and
the development owner) and by not requiring an undated development agreement in line with
the legal CCR documents.
It is the responsibility of the City of Meridian to serve its citizens with all legal due diligence. If
the City of Meridian does not reverse the rezoning of this particulaz property back to R4 as
required in legal contracts, legal recourse by hundreds of homeowners could result. Also, lack of
action by the City of Meridian and the developer may be construed as fraudulent.
Property owners throughout the subdivision were not informed of this rezoning change and did not
receive any updated contractual information from the developer regarding the change from R4 to
R15.
Respect ly Su fitted
Martin J. Comorosky
7/12/2012
G~
~~ ~~~~`
Margo E. Comorosky
7/12/2012
~~
/~
I
ADA COUNTY REI~RDER J. DAVID tVAVARRO
eO~E H1Atq 9113 116 PM
OEPUTY Bonnie OberblNiC '~I ~"I~~~I~~'~'~~'~n ~ ~~
RECIUtDEO-REQUEST OF N
Title One 1631~327~
a~u~rt aae ~
__ _--- -
n~c~~ ARATION
FOR
CEDARS RfNGS SUBDIV{SION NO. 1
THIS DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS bNDHowellR-Murdoch
FOR CEDAR SPRINGS SUBDIVISIONG a0 or1 orS'Declarant) whose address is
Development Corporation, (hereinafter
4822 N. Rosepoint Way, Suite C, Boise, Idaho 83713.
ARTICLE 1: RECITALS
o•~+r+or+y Covered. The Property subject to this Declaration of
1.1
Covenants, Conditions and. Restrictions thereinafter refer~eod which Decontained n
"CC&R's") is that property in Ada County, State of Ida ,
Cedar Springs Subdivision No. 1, and which is legally seasrrnay here Wafter be
attached hereto, together wn of these CC&R's and the Cedar Springs Neighborhood
brought within the lunsd~ct~o
Association, Inc.
1.2 Annexa ion o ~-ao o a~ rru 6• M o --• . ____
CC&R's. Additional phases of Cedar Springs Subdivision these CC&R's. In t e event
Subdivision No. 2) are contemplated to be annexed mt
hat an other properties are annexed into these CC&R's the ecorded Declaration of
t Y the r
also be subject to these CC&Rrt ew 11 be underthe unsdiction of the Association as
Annexation. All annexed props Y
set nut:below. These CG&R's and any DeclarationsEach annexed property may have
together as if all had. been done at the same time
different covenants and building restrictions and differe(easo here nand anpannexed
to that annexed property. However, all Common A
Page 1 of 37
CEDAR SPRINGS SUBDIVISION CC&R's c~z-~o-~~2~
properties shall be for the benefit of all Owners in this subdivision and in the
annexed properties. Cedar Springs Neighborhood Association, Inc. shall own, operate
and manage all Common Areas in this subdivision and all annexed properties as if all
were in one subdivision. In the-event that any other properties are annexed, this
Declaration sh abbe referred to as the "Master" Declaration.
1.3 Nofice of Development of Later Phases of Cedar Surinas Subdivision
depiction of the preliminary plat of CedarSprings Subdivision ~s attached hereto as
Exhibit C. Notice is hereby given to all. Owners that this configuration is subject to
change and that future .portions of the subdivision, if developed, may be developed
differently. Declarant is under no obligation to develop later phases of this
subdivision or to develop any later phases in any particular manner or order.
Notice is also given to-all Owners in Cedar Springs Subdivisions that some
later phases of Cedar Springs Subdivision, including, but not limited to, those phases
or portions of Cedar Springs Subdivision that are depicted on Exhibit C as possible
"Phase 4" and possible "Phase 5" are intended to be developed by Declarant, and
may be developed by Declarant,.. as some form or commercial, office, retail, or other
related _business uses. A portion may, or may not, also be developed as a school
site..lf the business Lots are-so developed for business uses,-reach of the business-
Lot phases wilt have its own separate- business Covenants,' Conditions and
Restrictions for that particular business phase, whatever that phase may be. The
Lots or parcels in a business phase (or any school site)- shall not be part of, or
subject to, these CC&R's and the Owners thereof shall have no votes in the Cedar
Springs Neighborhood Association; Provided, however, that each of the Lots or
parcels in the business phases, o~r school site, may be connected to the pressurized
urban irrigation system (PUTS) of Cedar Springs Subdivision. If connected., the
Owners of these Lots or parcels shall pay their proportionate share of all operation
and maintenance costs of the PUTS and their proportionate share of the water costs
relating to these Lots or parcels. `In -the event that the school site or the busines
phases are not developed for schooF or business uses and are developed as s' gle
family residential uses hen the Lots therein shall be subject o these CC&R's hen,
and if; annexed ilia ~hes~ CC&R`s
1.4 Puroose of Declaration. The purpose of this Declaration is to set forth
the basic restrictions, covenants, limitations, easements, conditions and equitable
servitudes that will apply to the development and use of the Property. This
Declaration is designed to preserve the Property`s value, desirability and
attractiveness, and to guarantee adequate maintenance of the Common Area, and
any Improvements located thereon.
CEDAt~ SPRINGS SUBpIVIS10N CC&R's t12-~o-2002 Rage 2 of 37
r
.
~~__~~..
t
V?
~_
_-.~-- _-- _-- -- --= F= ~ ~
~ ~ ~
_ ~ a ~
,_ ,~ ~
_ s ^
'~ i y~ = 1..__ _' ~ ~
I - - ~` '
a F ~ J' i
~ s ~ _ ° Q
e =
I \``'T~,
1
1 „ •~ ~
~---- a '
i - ~_ - _
_ _ _ _ '
_-`~ _ ,. ~
-` ~_~ _
~-
~ ~ - _ _ / a-
J i l ~-. ~ ,
-~ .
__ __~_i
: ~
i
,_ - --~ ,r_, ~,
", - ~ ~
. ~ _ - A !1~
_ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
R ! 1
t ~ /~
_ v ~ ~
_ ..-~ ~ ) I
_ •v.
i
~ ~~
NEAL COLBORN PLLC
GARY L. NEAL* 216 W. JEFFERSON TELE: (208) 343-5931
JAMES W. COLBORN** P.O. BOX 1826 FAX: (208) 343-5807
ERIC J. SCOTT BOISE, IDAHO 83702 E-Mail: info@IdahoRealEstateLaw.com
www.IdahoRealEstateLaw. com
* A1soAdmittedinOregon
**Also Admitted in Washington
July 12, 2012
Via Personal Delivery
Meridian City Clerk's Office
33 E. Broadway Avenue
Meridian, Idaho 83642
Re: PP 12-010 & CUP 12-006
To Whom it May Concern:
This letter is in reference to the July 19, 2012 public hearing of the Meridian
Planning and Zoning Commission of the City of Meridian pertaining to the Applicant's
efforts to okaain preliminary plat approval consisting of five (5) building lots on 2.39 acres of
land as well as approval of amulti-family development consisting of 36 units.
I have been retained by the Cedar Springs Neighborhood Association, Inc. to
address certain concerns that have been raised by a number of homeowners that live in
that subdivision. A large number of homeowners have strong opinions conceming the
proposed development. The Association has requested that I submit on its behalf the
enclosed petition containing the original signatures of a significant number of residents in
the subdivision. The petition specifically references an issue concerning the process
through which the subject property was rezoned from R-4 to R-15.
The strong opinions articulated by the homeowners derive from the fact that when
they were induced by the developer to purchase lots in the subdivision they were assured
that the subject property would not be developed in the manner that is now being sought.
The Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions for Cedar Springs Subdivision
City Clerk LTR 07-12-12
No. 1 was recorded on January 8th, 2003 and provided to each of the lot purchasers prior
to the closing of their purchase. Consistent with the verbal representations made by agents
of the developer, the contemplated use was "some form o[fi] commercial, office, retail, or
other related business uses." The developer also stated that it was possible that a portion
could be used as a school site. My client has no objection to those intended uses. The lot
purchasers were provided notice before they closed the transaction that the property could
be developed in that manner. The developer also suggested that in the event that the
subject property was not developed for business or school use any single family home
located on the subject property would be subject to the same or similar covenants. The
homeowners are upset because no effort has been made to reach out to them to explain
the reasoning behind the current proposed use.
Pursuant to rezone application RZ 04-014, the developer sought rezoning of the
subject properly without disclosure to the homeowners who had already purchased lots,
and those who would later purchase lots, that the contemplated use would be significantly
different than those set forth in the covenants. The circumstances attendant with the rezone
should be revisited and those issues raised in the petition explained. The Association also
has no objection to those uses allowed in an R-4 zone.
The Association does not believe that the posting requirements of UDC 11-5A-5
have been met but will further comment on this issue after the Applicant provides proof of
property posting.
The relevance of the applicable covenants is clear after reviewing the Applicant's
claim that the currently proposed development is entitled to be connected to the existing
pressurized irrigation system, presumably the system maintained by the Association,
when the Association has not agreed to that use.
Many of the homeowners have voiced concerns over the issue of safety. The issues
relate primarily to the unique circumstances attendant with the adjacent Settlers Park. The
Park's location has historically created parking and traffic demand which exceeds the
neighborhood's capacity to comfortably accommodate the increased use. The Applicant's
development will increase those stressors without mitigation. The Association contends
that increased lighting, additional parking and installation of crosswalks is necessary to
reduce the risks of injury or death.
The Association understands that this property can and should be developed.
Good faith and fair play requires that it be developed in a manner which was promised by
the developer and in a manner which will not be detrimental to the public health, safety or
City Clerk LTR 07-12-12
general welfare of the local homeowners and other visitors to the neighborhood.
Please contact me if you have any further questions or concerns.
Sincerely:
NEAL COLBORN PLLC
~~N~
Gary L. Neal
enc.
Cc: Cedar Springs Neighborhood Association, Inc.
City Clerk LTR 07-12-12
Petition a ainst the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an dated development agreement from the
plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
DATE' N
A
ME - ` ADDRESS SIGNATURE
~
!
~.
J/-Z~ /.Z,
~ ~ ~
~ 7~ ~ ~~ a ~
~ r
~ Z~CI Z ~ C~ wocD 38 i3 N E~.ssN o7~ v~ ;~~,.
S rL. ~~. ~r~ ~ 3847 N~ ~Els,,.~~. ~,
r~ ~. ~ ~~~ 38 ~ ~ °
5 ~. .~
Petition a ainst the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho..
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an dated development agreement from the
plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedaz Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
DATE NAME ' ADDRESS SIGNATURE
s i~ 7~,~vLti Tf/~A~ ~ 375 N ~slt~cw w A y d~/C
5~~z~t C1~ ~eee., ~ 3 S ~ r l~- ~ ,~e,ea n ~-~
/2 ~ e G~~1~e- ~7`.3 /V ~ rr~
~NNi~£K- E~~.,i
ZZ i P ~ ski ~ ~:
e ~ ~
~h ~, ~-
' ~,.,~, t ~e k~ .~ b kt ~ S~ reed-
aw ~ ~ ~ ~-@
2¢ ~ ~~- ~~
C ~ ' ~v v ~. f
52`~ ~ ~ C~~~ e/~ c i
To William B. HerbertlPresident Cedar Springs HOA
Regarding the Ashby & Meridian Rd petition. We own a property located
at 615 W. Blake St., Meridian, ID 83646. It is titled to The Evans Family Trust.
We are both Trustees. We would like to add our name electronically via this
email to the petition against the proposed building of an apartment building
located at the southwest corner of N. Meridian Rd and W. Ashby Dr.
Regards,
John R. EvanslTrustee for The Evans Family Trust
~ ~~.-
'~ggy L. EvanslTrustee for The Evans Family Trust
-~
~ ;
Our Home Address: 10452 W. Surrey Dr.
Littleton, CO 80127-1121
Home Phone # 303-979-2881
. ., ;
Email Address: Fi;~. ~r~~~~ ~- J ~_. r~__t~ ~~; ~,~~
Fax # 303-979-0116
w
Petition against the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an updated development agreement from the
plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
DATE NAME- ADDRESS SIGNATURE
b ~
~~~ ~
~-~6'1 U c/< If ~ ~/ ~ G- 6 3 3 iV Sr/~-iv Fps ~ p
Nul v ~~ /v~ Nl~s
,{
l~/
9L<~'-Fi y `
~ /~~ 5 ~ ~O
!~~l~\/ S !,
:v
is
0
o>
~ -n T, ,, -n „ -n „ m m -n m m „ m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m
U c~
° c~
O c~
° c~
O
~
1
(p 1
N 1
N 1
ill 1
N 1
iU 1
N "'1
iU 1
N 1
~ 1
N 1
N l
tv 1
N Vl Ul !p Vl fA fp U1 fA Vl dl Ul fA y N N
7 N f%1
7 U7 Ul
7 Ul
7 !A
7 Vl
7 fn
7 l
7
7
7
7
7
~p 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 0 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 0 7 7 7 7 7 0
0 7
0 0
0 7
0 0 7
0 0 7
0 0 0 0 0 0 o m m m m ~
° a n n n a a
0 a
0 n
0 a
0 n
0 a
0 n
0 n
0 o
~ 0
~ 0
~ 0
~ 0
~ 0
~ 0
~ 0
~ 0
~ 0
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
~
r
r
~. 0
> 0
> 0
> 0
> 0
> > > > > > > 3 ° m m m m cp m cu m m m m m m m m co m m m m
W m
W co
W m
W m
W
O)
W
~ o
~
i7
S W W W W W W W W W W W W W W
c0 W
LO W
LO W
c0 W
00 W
00 W
00 W
00 W
OD W
OD W
V W
V W
V W
V W
V W
V W
V W
0 W
0 0 O O O O N O W CT
~
W ip
-• pD
V OD
O) OD
Ut 00
•P 00
? 00
N OD
N OD
O V
Oo V
V V
O) V
Cn
~
V
O
•P
O)
N
O
O
W
V
00
O
~
.A
V
•P
N
~
W
~
N
LO
V
f0
O)
V
LO
V
Go
~A
N
~
~
O
O
Oo
~
V
N
O
W ~a
?
N
V
N
N ~
W
O •A V O LO l~ -~ ? W Ut V O CD -
N cc `
1 ` ~ 1
~ (n ~v G~ v Q m (n
" `
N Q Z ~
° = fn <C
C m <C
< ~ 2 D D D ~- -i r _~ m ~- ~ ~ D Cn ~ ~ ~ D C~ 0 ~ 2 ~
p
tT S
(D
- S
= iU
~ GF1
y
c O
C
o Cl
3 D
f^
<
~
c O
C
o °
p~ O"
O
` N
2 j
° l
D
y N
7
~ ~ 01
~ _
~
fD ^^
S ai
S ~
-• SU
~ ~
N n
S n ~
C ~
7c y
fD ~
O
' 47
~ ~
fD fyD fD ~ n
-~
o
` N
ip <
O. S
7 d ~_
°
m
~ °•
w o .
~ <
D v m
~ m
v y v
y >
<
~ >
< ~ -
v °
~ ~
r °
~ y m
~ n
o
' o
°
•G r;
Z ~ °
m c>
m m
m ~
fn ~?.
s ?i ~ -o °
W y
m ~ D c c
fD i
a
~ <
~ -~ ~
-~ ~
N
z
n
C7
<
~ ~
~
~ y
D ~
a ~
~
D
= `
~ oo
~ D -i
n
W m
m G~
~ ~
~ n
m oo
d 6
N y cl
? m
r r
n n
ai '
o
W
~ L
~ W
~ -n
of m
° p
m W
~ ` w
< c• m
o
v
- m
7 m
-+ ~
y °
~ C7
01 T.
ul
C ~
~ o
S n
N i
n
°
y o
S ~
~ ~
Cl o
N Q
7C °
S p
fD sv
~ ~
N W
N ,.
~ ~
O =•
fD c
.. ~
iti1 °
fD °
3 ~
(/1 m ~
7 °
~r
fp
~
N ~_
<
'a m n~i °
y O W Cn fD ~-' ~` y ~ fD N O ~ ~ W -,
° `G n d W N •+• ~ Q ~ ~ O 3 ~ fD r; ` < O- ~• C7 "D
p
7 O
n ~
V N
nl `G
Gl O
> N
> W
.,a O
° L
m p
~ O
> K
> ~
W v
~ ~ ~
m ~
n O
~
rn r
y ~
O L
m ~
N N
v ~
y ~
w ~, 3 ~
°• p m
< ~
n ~
o y
v ~
c N
(~ S
~ .
~. O
c7
g
~ al
LO
Z °
O ao
Ul -o
y w
oo ~
N w
OD °
7 tv
~ m ~
N V
~ °` ~
` °
D m
O o
Z m
7 al
~ ~
S
p
? ~
j w
~ V
~ .p
W D
n c
s ol
L ~•
fD ~
~ ~ m
.. n
~ nl
fl y
N ~.
N G~
fD o
7
N ~
~ TI
w fD
T CO =
' ?
~ ~
v N
w =ri
m (D
v N
Q
~
Z ~
C~
?
W fD
m
c ~
m _+:
c~
m
~
o
z ~ r
~
o
~ W
o N
r ,<
> ~
> n
O y
o .
m
Q ~
- fD
° LD
-
? n .
~ Z
T n
al ? ~, ? n `' m ~ ~ r ~ ~ ca ~ ° ~ m y o1 ~ ~ N ~ S Q o p
~< 0 ~
~
LD -n
N o ca
!O ~
p n
C7 m °
~ m
N ,'
~ _
7 ~
D ~
~
N ~
v
~ w
O 'r
W w
c0 ~
-
fD o
fD m
O ~
W ~ o
~ v
N m
y y
°
< W
V W
V ~
W
O)
~ r
< W
N m y
'O c
~ ° 0
n
p
7
7
n
D
<
~
n
O
N
-~ N
7
~
c'
p
fl•
W
oo
to
fD
L
~
it
°-
O
VO
~
N
0
~'
~
~
W O
O
.p
N
°
O
C
C
c
^'
p
O
s
fD
LD
p
N
~
~
°
j
Oo
~
~
S
~
~
W
j
~.
00
-'
p
N
• •
,
V
O
p
°- O
7 ~ Q 7
D y
O n
O
7 7
Q
~ 0
7 0
(T 7
w 0
S
° CO
cn 7
D Z
m 0
? Z O
N
a N
•< ~
O
~ V
Z
. ~
~
~ n
W N
`< V
N fp C
<
° c
fD Z Z y
o
Z O
N
rn p
3 Z p
j
(p
m 61
< 7
W
rn N
~
to <
O
, L
W
c
D m o m °
w D <
N < ? oVO O ~ m u, m m
y ,
< ~ z m N
O ~° ~ V ~ ~c cn m m ° m o m ,.
l d ~
l
G
p cn •
~
~
`< N
7 ~
°: K
N 7
C 00
~' ~
O
C fD
p -~
-•~ V 7
W O
7 7
p ~
O m
7
O
'y"" fD
m fp
7 C
< w
Z ~
Q fn
S ~•
a ~
p ~ y
0 y'
0 W
0 W
7 y'
p fD
W V!
7 ri
y. y •
Z
~ _~
< N
_I N
7
~ C
fD C1
p O)
V lD ~A
Z c
fD 7
r: C
N Cl
7
n Z
g V
V ••
:17 N
~ -~
fD
O ~
fD N
~ O:
N
=•
O
C
m :
= Ol
n
~ Gl
7 p
d. ~
~p ~
fD ~
N O
Z O
~
fD l
~ O
O O
N 7
°
~ W
N
m ip LC
~ Q
c 7C
(n
~ ?~
°' O
m ~
~
~ ~ ~
O 7
(D O ,
N O
Z O
:v ~p
-~ ~ fD
< ~
01 ? O
~ O N
y Vl
' -
Q <
m
4 fl1
7 O
0 C
« C ~ W
Z
G
O N N•
p ~ ~
0 ~
7 .•.
y
n
m (D
°.
a °
~
° al
cn d •
i
m
~ fD
°
Q W ~.
n
' O
D °
n
~ a
o
°~ iu
`<
~
o~i
`<
~
a
m
oni
m
~
d
`<
~ >
°
°
m
o
'm
~
-
m
(~
`~
~
w
v
~ 7
°-
°
m
~
.~
~-
o
~ 0
c
~'
<
m
;~
~ ~ ~ o ~• y d
7 ~ ~
N
a. ~
~
~ ~
(D
Tl o
N
~ ~ CC
< °
00
S ~?
»: ~
lD ~
fD ~
O
~
.Z7 w•
p ~
N ~
~
Z
~ y to
iti W
-
Q.
ol
s >
o w
w
o
a
m
a
m °
~ >
a o
<
a p
c
° D
< °
°-
o
D
° _
°'
~
°,
m m
°
a °
a o
v w
w
rn `<
~ m
~
d p
°
cn ~
m
`< 00
°'
o v
~< w
rn o
w o
-,
° -,
a ~
Q ~
o m
-,
d. o
iv
n
~
m °
°
d o
N
•p m
w+
.~ m
~
o: m
~<
co
.p °
0 -
'*
0
O .
C1 A S S G1 fD i11 ~ 7 to S p 01 a ~ N .•. A ~ ~
0 flj 61 N
m
7
O
~
N
N
Q
~ ~ O ° °
w ~
~ p O p N ~
~ D
m ~ 0 7 O
a m
ct °~ C.
e 7
' ~
fD• ~ O y
< ~
rn 0
~ 7 7
a 01
`< ~ ~
~ m
m -_+
d ~ O
m O (
O
W
~ w
w oo
w rn ~ ~
w n
D ao
W Q
~ °; y w
~ ~
~ n ~ °1• l
? m W a
m _ ~ a
~. ~ ~
m a
° ~
' ~ a
v ~
~ ~ _
d ~ - n
rn ~ ~' rn °: ~ m ~ ~ ul ~ ~
D o o o
i
S o o s °-• ° m ~ o o = ~'
° o
? m 3• v ? S
° o. ~?
O O N
7 O N
O) O -
n ~
-
n ~
Q
OD
w O
OD
O
(7 d
5 °
00 N
-
D. C7
Ol Oo
W
OD
01
°D
C1
fl;
OD
w
=
fi
n
v S
O O
~
°
a cn
rn ul
S
m -•
°
? o
oo
°l w
o w
~ nl o w
~ -
n m
S
°
m rn
~ w
~ ?
n
~ V
~, m
o r
~ co
~• 00
w
~ _.
cl
a oo ° rn
w ~ rn rn ° rn o o ~ °~ rn a
i rn ~ Q o m of oo $j ~ m
~~
, ? d rn w ~ o ni s ~ ? w rn
w
W
O ~
O .
H O O W p~~
p
A W N O ~ N ~ ~
P O) W ~ p 0 A ~ W 7 0
O) ~ to N O CO ~ ~ pp
O O ~
o °~
of
m
N
.~
~ p
fD
-~
N
tC
7
C
i
i
• u~ ~
v
d
.~ o
~_
LQ
7
C
N
7
0
n
O
0
Q.
N
7
N
fl.
y~
O
7
f~Df
eY
fD
N
0~
r
r
A
'~
0
~.
~o
~+
Petition a ainst the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an updated development a~eement from the
plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
~~
DA N ADDRESS SI A U
~~. ~ ~ 1/1 ~' ~ Y~~;~ ~ '
Z I ~ (Zt C. S TU NRE,^/(~£~l ~ ~ Z- 1 W /~/"~Un) "~ ~
5 ~-~
~ ~~ a ~ Ne. - z~ c~
S8~ I,J ~~
~ ~'~,~ ~~ i
'c.~e.
~'~ ~•a,~l~ ~ON~'~ly~ 5 a d ~, lam- d~ `- . d
~~
Z2 ~ ~ - Gw<< ~~~ S~` <
o
7 G ,~^
~ ~ 1 ~" I r ,, n•" ~ ~~
VJ ~ W . ~~ ~J 1~• "1
~~~~ i Z. S N i~N~ ,~ . ~ ~~ ~~~ ~,~I. ~ y ~ E
~l~ ~ ~ ~ ~c<< 6 ,
~~ i -~ n/ ~ ~~~ ~ .
s3 d-soh
~
~ t ~.~~~ ,.
^
~~ / ~ l~t~T ~" ~i2
2- ~ L tJ~-~1,~ ~r'~°a ~y2 tJ ~S r4'v'~ `~'~-
Petition against the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an dated development agreement from the
plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
DATE NAME - ADDRESS SIGNATURE
U>kl ieL~ ~'L~~ ~88~' Rf2 o t~v ,fix
~ ~L ~~ ~ l~~ ~~~ ~ ~~ 3~ ~l ~/ , ,B~/~~D~J r
s/~l~o, ~T ~H a ~~l ~ .~ ~ ~ ,~, l,~~s ~ ~ , ~ ~'
e ~ ~.
r-~.
~(~/la ~~ E rrnr~ 1.~.~hs ~~..~1~ ~~~~ (,~ i
~6 /` 3
i
Petition against the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an dated development a~eement from the
plot owner-(Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
DATE NAME ' ADDRESS SIGNATURE
! ~ ~ t~-- ~ ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ z n<. ~f ~~ ~~~ PL ~
~~ 7 9U. ~CCx~~s 1,(~
S ~~ ~~~ 36~~ ~
v
Petition against the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9124/04) by not requesting an updated development agreement from the
plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
ATE NAME ADDRESS SIGNATURE
J - /6-lZ I
f 4 r
-f'1 /
/V , fcln
J6~/
~~ ~ ~ 0
3 ~ ~ /J~ I
5~~1p' ~2i ~\M O~V \S ~~ ~~ ` I• S~0.vt~a~ ~ acrt..
7 fit fly k 1~~ ~~~ ~..~~ '1'~1.~~ ~.
i c--
~-
-~ h-l~ ~-a ~ ~Q ~~ ~~So N. G~~fNw; ~~ W x
f b ~~_ '` mil ~ / ~ , ~ ~ ~G/ ~",,~ ~ ` KL ~~ " ~ _.T
'' Iii ~ ~ ~ 3~fi 1 C~ ~~ G~ ' ~, w-~
2 H vJ ~G
1~-~~ ~1~ ~ Ic m~i ,~3'l'S1, N~~~c:~ ~ ,.....~
2 ~ ~~ r.
r
r
Petition against the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an updated development a,Qreement from the
plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
-DATE NAME- ADDRESS SIGNATURE '
5 3 ~.ore~1"e K~~1c.1 t~ ~-~ ~-
z3 ~ a~ te'a'
Z3 ~T~1~~T ~-~i~6- !63 uJ. GZnro~J sT
5~~ .~ iol on ~'r.
~l
~ -~ ~ a~ 3 ( ~ , ~ rs tN~.
.~I~ C ~ i ~jV ~tl -7$L 'S
5 z~ l~Ul" AUmi ~ 1~'' 3 X88 r~• A 1PXis V~Ip , .
~~ `
os 2 11U• ~ ; a
/ Sri s.~h ~ ~ ,~ 3~~ ~ N . ~ t~x~ ~ ~-i ~-
a ' ~ ~.-~ ~ 38a3
Petition against the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an updated development agreement from the
plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
DATE NAME ' ADDRESS IGN URE
S ~ Z-3 v~~ Call ~0 ~/e.
~3 ~ 3 7G~ ! ~ reNc~, ~ -
O~ l~A~ 1 b ~ ~~ 1V ~ ~~~P.f/l~l i
5 G~n~ ' ~Q~1 ~' ~ba . GTeen~~~i
2 (,~, CJe~'c
c7I?/sr
t
~. ~~N ~v
la ~~l ,U~~ ~ ~s~/ i~ ,' v~-
~~~.3 [~ ~~s-~ 63 s-~--
`~~2'~ ~l~~b~~ Corey 5q 5 w ~ ln~~e I e ~ s-~
Z~ S ~ i~~.c N S
5 Z~ ~r ~~~~ ~ 33 /1~ ~'~e~w ~c Wl~. ~
~ ~ ~ ~~ /~ .
3 ~~ /V• ~-
S° 23 ~ y IV. ~h o
J- ~ ~` ~ v D
4'
Petition against the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located at
the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36 multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-15
(RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an dated development agreement from the
plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
D TE N E - - ADDRESS SI~3 ATU E
5 LrJ / ~
~ ~~ /V- (~ PS ~
~ r L~~ ~~ ~ °~c®w , 2 ~ ~ ~
(2 ~ ~~~c~C~ ~~' 6 ~ ~1 ` 4~1 ~+c~
~ ~2" ~z T~ ~I k iN~i77~~ 3gy~ ~, ~'~u~ /~ ~ ~m~'~
a~
~ ~ ~~~~~
es ---- -- _ _
J a~ I S I-! r~ e~ 1iG'~ L
ti / rY-4r~, m~~~ h 3~0~ N . ~Ge
` ~
It~l ~l 2 ~-I/ Ih~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r
5~Z yll ~' E~ - ~g ~ /~~ ~~
~ a4 ~ ~ N. PYiez ~~
5 Z~ 1 1~~1 ~~ ~:e ~ ~ (~ ~ ( ~ . ~V ~ C~ wa ~ C
S ~ ~~~~ ~~
~ ~~ ~j ~ ~ ~ OJ ~2i Ce. VJ
J/ ~ ~~. ~ ~i' ~
o"Z 1-
Petition against the Conditional Use Permit for Settlers Park LLC property located
at the southwest corner of W. Ashby Street and North Meridian Road, Meridian Idaho.
This conditional use permit is being requested for approximately 36 multi-family units on
a 2.39 acre plot at the above stated address. We contest that the City of Meridian failed
to complete the legal land use process for changing the original zoning from R-4 to R-
15 (RZ#04-014 filed 9/24/04) by not requesting an dated development agreement from
the plot owner (Hal Murdock Development) at the time of rezoning. Those signing this
petition below are residents of the Cedar Springs Subdivision and were not previously
informed of this zoning change.
PLEASE PRINT
DATE NAME ADDRESS SIGNATURE
6/1/12 Lo al L Morrow 3787 N Alexis Wa ,Meridian, ID Ilm
6/1/12 Annette Morrow 3878 N Alexis Wa ,Meridian, Id am
~ '
To William B. Herbert/President Cedar Springs HOA
Regarding the Ashby & Meridian Rd petition. We own a property located
at 615 W. Blake St., Meridian, ID 83646. It is titled to The Evans Family Trust.
We are both Trustees. We would like to add our name electronically via this
email to the petition against the proposed building of an apartment building
located at the southwest corner of N. Meridian Rd and W. Ashby Dr.
Regards,
John R. EvanslTrustee for The Evans Family Trust
'Peggy L. Evans/Trustee for The Evans Family Trust
1 r
,~,~
Our Home A-ddress: 10452 W. Surrey Dr.
Littleton, CO 80127-1121
Home Phone # 303-979-2881
Email Address: ~~_ ~.. ~+~_ ~ ~ ~ < ~,;~ ,w.:.. ~ ~,
Fax # 303-979-0116