Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMartell, Bill & Lynn CUPOFFICIALS WILLIAM G. BERG, JR., City Clerk JANICE L. SMITH, City Treasurer GARY D. SMITH, P.E., City Engineer BRUCE D. STUART, Water Works Supt. JOHN T SHAWCROFT, Waste Water Supt. DENNIS J. SUMMERS, Parks Supt. SHARI L. STILES, P & Z Administrator PATTY A. WOLFKIEL, DMV Supervisor KENNETH W. BOWERS, Fire Chief W.L. "BILL" GORDON, Police Chief WAYNE G. CROOKSTON, JR., Attorney • HUB OF TREASURE VALLEY COUNCIL MEMBERS A Good Place to Live WALT W. MORROW, President CITY OF MERIDIAN RONALD R. TOLSMA REE C GLENN R. BENTLE 33 EAST IDAHO MERIDIAN, IDAHO 83642 P & Z COMMISSION Phone (208) 888-4433 • FAX (208) 887-4813 JIM JOHNSON, Chairman Public WorksBuilding Department (208) 887-2211 MALCOLM MACCOY Motor Vehicle/Drivers License (208) 888-4443 KEITH BORUP RON MANNING ROBERT D. CORRIE BYRON SMITH Mayor TRANSMITTAL TO AGENCIES FOR COMMENTS ON DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS WITH THE CITY OF MERIDIAN To insure that your comments and recommendations will be considered by the Meridian Planning & Zoning Commission, please submit your comments and recommendation to Meridian City Hall, Attn: Will Berg, City Clerk by: September 2, 1997 TRANSMITTAL DATE: 8/20/97 HEARING DATE: 9/9/97 REQUEST: Conditional Use Permit for a beer. wine and liauor sports bar BY: William & Lvnn Martell LOCATION OF PROPERTY OR PROJECT: Corner of Franklin and Linder Roads JIM JOHNSON, P/Z MALCOLM MACCOY, P/Z RON MANNING, P/Z BYRON SMITH, P/Z KEITH BORUP, P/Z BOB CORRIE, MAYOR RONALD TOLSMA, C/C CHARLIE ROUNTREE, C/C WALT MORROW, C/C GLENN BENTLEY, C/C WATER DEPARTMENT SEWER DEPARTMENT BUILDING DEPARTMENT FIItE DEPARTMENT POLICE DEPARTMENT CITY ATTORNEY CITY ENGINEER CITY PLANNER MERIDIAN SCHOOL DISTRICT MERIDIAN POST OFFICE (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) ADA COUNTY HIGHWAY DISTRICT ADA PLANNING ASSOCIATION CENTRAL DISTRICT HEALTH NAMPA MERIDIAN IRRIGATION DISTRICT SETTLERS IlZRIGATION DISTRICT IDAHO POWER CO. (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) U.S. WEST (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) INTERMOUNTAIN GAS (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) BUREAU OF RECLAMATION (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) CITY FILES OTHER: YOUR CONCISE REMARKS: CITY OF MERIDIAN APPLICATION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NAME: Lv iil / i 1.4.-,~ ~- L',~,~,~c~ I~YI ~.d 1~P ADDRESS:_ C ~~ti 2~? a T` /-~/1 i¢,~'/j~~ GENERAL LOCATION: ~~~i ~irJ~T ~~ ~ DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED CONDITIONAL USE: r ~ PHONE: ^ $ "- %~~ ~ A ZONING CLASSIFICATION: I certify that the information contained herein is true and correct. .~ a~~ Signature o App 'cant Social Security Number Ss5° ~e - 7G~g LEGAL NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Pursuant to established procedure, NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Meridian Planning and Zoning Commission will hold a Public Hearing in the Meridian City Hall on at _.m. The purpose of the Hearing is to consider a CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT submitted by for the property generally described as located at SUBDIVISION, BLOCK ,LOT TO • • 1. William & Lynn Martell 2241 N.W. 10th Meridian, ID 83642 2. G. Matthew Thomas 7701 Moon Valley Rd Eagle, ID 83616 3. See Attached 4. See Attached 5. Vacant Land 6. Vacant Land 7. Sports Bar 8. C.C. 9. See Attached 10. See Attached 11. This will be a good location for Business. There are no residential dwellings close and with Franklin widening this will be a main road to Nampa from Meridian. 12. To be provided by Meridian 13. 11eed~ed ~~~ 14. See Attached 15. See Attached 16. See Attached AFFIDAVIT OF LEGAL INTEREST STATE OF IDAHO ) ) ss COUNTY OF ADA ) I, _ C . ~ ~~T 1-I'~'V~ I f-EO hh (~S D ~11DDt~ l4Gl.~ (name) (address) ~.~Gp r ~D~ ~ being first duly sworn upon 1~ oath, depose and say: (city) (state) 1. That I am the record owner of the property described on the attached, and I grant my permission to Ken Sorrells with Re/Max Real Estate Professionals 29 e. Fairview, Meridian, ID 83542 (name) (address) to submit the accompanying application pertaining to that property. 2. I agree to indemnify, defend and hold (~~C~ ~ p/_~,~ and it's employees harmless from any claim or liability resulting from any dispute as to the statements contained herein or as to the ownership of the propertywhich is the subject of the application. Dated this ~ ~ T tt day of ~~J 1~~.- , I g (Signature) .SULSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me the day and year first above written. .. Notary Pu151~ for Idaho Residing at My Commission Expires: (0 ' / Z' 9~ u • . The property will be posted 1 week before the hearing stating they have applied for a Conditional Use Permit or Zoning. There must be a signed affidavit that this will be done as part of the application. ~/~ ; I hereby agree to pay any additional sewer, water or trash fees or charges if any are associated with this property. I also agree that we will post the property stating that we have applied for a conditional use permit. ~~ ~ ~~ STATE OF IDAHO ) SS COUNTY OF %~ ~~ ) On This ~Z day of ~~ c.- , in the yeaz`7 before me, a Notary Public in and for said State, personally appeared , j'a L ~r~`J ,known or identified tom to b e person(s) wh se name(s) s d to the within Instrument, and acknowledged to me that ~ xecuted the same. Public of Idaho g at Boise, Idaho ~,~y~ ssion Expires: j~ /S~Cvw ~. E s t. s: rc. i' i ,`~~'~' '~' ~1601001~14 4 ,~ ,. •. ..:~~ ~` tN , : A. •... ~ ~ ~ f~C} AT 1'ME SOUTHWEBT;CAAI~IER.OP 8N 1l, tOWNBHIP aTIORTH, RANGE t WEBT OF ~(ZiWJ"~pA'r,OUNT~tn (GANG, ~r~!l~-RFJU.. OF BB¢INMNOi: '~,J,QE17Ji,Q;~EpREE Off' WF$T A40Np. WEBT~RI:Y tlQUNDARIY Od3AiD SECTION t2 FOR A '~ Ofis~S27~37"!'L~ET TO /1 I!OINf IN CINDER ROAta; T}A~(110F, ~1GlpTH Rs O~Qf~k~B QO'`~A6T AI:ONp TFIE NORM 910 OF E~tl8TIN0 EA8T-WEST FENCE FOR A G11~TAl~E;C~E95i:R81tCET,TO aat CM ANb~ IRON~PIN TH~NC:F,~~01,11'H 0 DEC3RE6 07' WEST FOR+~:DIBTANCB OR a42.a0.FEE1' TO A POIM I. SOUtF1 BQy~I Y, qF 8Np;8EGTIDN.t><.(~iRlICH 18IN.MIDOLE,OF U.8: MIpHWAY I90 AND PRIWIO.IN ROADIE '~} ~, zpp ,.WE87,J~t,ONO 80V1M dOUNDMY OF 8A10 6ECTION t! FOR A qr~~~~q~~'~'OrTF•$'REN«PIJICE'OR oEl11NNIN0. '',1'F~f~'f~741~71QN'iC'~NpWITHINUNPER:ItOADAND FRANIQ.IN IIOAD ~~>~~ ~ >- .;:~. ~'PUp1 !••"'A.. fr9i~*~tr ~ ~ '~9'~+,Gr'~ii fir, ~;c , ,r ~' M / ~~ i r ~~ .... ., i~ • ~ x 3 ss ' Oattsy oP.Ma 1 ,' •~ .an-this :~A7x1y~y of ~, 1993, bsfaze t», the unders~.g+ed, a,:NotatiyYvbl~~ end far s caaty end staCe, peroonallY aPPea'sd ~gy~tQiCB:'J. l4JUS~, k<nn,m dD aye to be the peroon dhoae nacre io sobacribed _ go:tho ooithir- ino.tsvme~+t, and aclawvlvdged to ms that he e~scvtad the seine'. • Ip.}~g$g Iil~SOP, I have hersunta sat ey himd end efff.xed ory official. Jaa~~~~~a dry and Peer in Chia cectifieate first abanre written. a'~` ONT ~''+~ g"`.. Nor M~`*N~~'4~e.'A¢ CT~R ~, ~ c ar ~° Besi at ae, Idaho ^. ,. ~.., '~.VbL~ J I 'r T ~ r~ ~r.~~a •F., ,::~: ,. ...ria WatxaeCy Deed-- Yage 2 -% r~~ , unr xt~x~~jcl~~,c. " ~ "fi:7^l 1~ i!s`~'•~ ~~~`` "~' ~ 16Ui0Ui3i3 ~~~ ; r ,~ ~` ~~°~ ,~, iay.: of.1~~~ tY 1993 befpre me, tie axlereignsd, ud: f~rr cows >end ,state. personally eppaned l DTIE.:[AXfSE,~d~sbend.@nd Mifa. ta~own m se m be _-- ____~ ~.e_:..r~~ .., M,.....lth~n inetzilnlnC. and lf~C~~they::~oc~Cpt~d tita om. ;` Y Fisvo t,ereunto-set bend imd affixed mY .~ ay nd.:~•yesr in this cariificsbe first sba~ve wrlttat• ~; r ,* ~ c ~ ' ~ at B~.s, Idnho f~ ~ y • _. _ ... w.._., _ .(' f~';fi~i~'":1r/~i,c :1379862 ~' ', ~ PIONEER TIT18 CO. ,h ... q. RECORGE~: 9YG~~~~O '93 SEP 10 fl~ 1119 iGU1UU1312 waRR,+xiY atira 4 ~;, t' ,:. ~•; :~~, ~' .. ~~ ~~; i ~. 'J: ~~ . >~ r 1 FOR VALUE RECEIVED, PA'1RICK L. HOUSP. and 8(7tdiLE HGITSE, husband and wife, LAWiWl~CE J. NDUSE, a carried nwn deaf with his tole and separ- ate property, the Grantors, do hereby grant, 6argalr-, sell and convey unto ZECHARL4H N. 8001HE, a single person. the Grantee, whose present mailing address ie 1550 West Franklin Road, Meridian, idehc x3642, the following described premises situated in the County of Ada, State of Idaho, more particularly described ns: 5EE ATTACHED LEGAI. DESCRIPiLON G'HICH IS INCORPORAI'~ RERF.IN BY REFERfl1CE. TG HAUL AND TO HOQD '11~ Said premises, with their appurtenances, unto the said Grantees, their heirs and ueigna forever. And the said Grantors do hereby covenant to and with the ssid 4lrantees that the Grantors are the owners in fee eL,Qle of said ptasdses, and that thoq ere lrae from all enanVbxancos ~xesspptt, (1) current taxes. l,evi~ea ad assessments far 1993 (2) rseervations, restrictions, and usemente of recard~ and that the Grantors eoi.ll warrant and defend the acme from all Iav+R~l claims whatsoever. Dated this v1Z~ day of ~ru~, 1993. .~~i~ ~ ~rfs.L atr. cse~~ ~/ ~ •~ouae e se . ~ . ,r'' ~~ July 8, 1997 I William Martell have read the contents and do verify that the information contained is true and correct . r William Martell D e i BILL & LYNN MARTELL 51211449104 MAGLECIC STEVEN C & PATRICIA R 65 CLEAR CREEK DR MERIDIAN ID 83642-5209 199 N CINDER RD 51211449102 WINGETT GARY & ROSALIE 2440 N PLAZA EMMETT ID 83617 0 N CINDER RD 51211449300 51211449220 51211449215 STORKAN OLIVER D & CAROL A 22491 CAN ADA RD STAR ID 83669-5018 1680 W FRANKLIN RD 0 N CINDER RD 0 N CINDER RD 51211449210 51211449200 PERSON SHIRLEY R 10409 ESTATE DR BOISE ID 83709-0318 0 W FRANKLIN RD 1684 W FRANKLIN RD 51212336100 WILLIAMSON ELAINE I 1200 W FRANKLIN RD MERIDIAN ID 83642-2417 O E FRANKLIN RD 51212336596 WILLIAMSON ELAINE I 1200 W FRANKLIN RD MERIDIAN ID 83642-2417 83579000040 MICHELS GLENN E & VIDA A 1097 CABARTON RD CASCADE ID 83611-5307 • 0 N CINDER AVE 0 83579000045 BEAMON JOHN & BETTY JO 160 N CINDER RD MERIDIAN ID 83642 83579000050 MAY ROY A & DONNA M 110 N CINDER RD MERIDIAN ID 83642-2439 51212336008 51212336020 THOMAS G MATTHEW 7701 MOON VALLEY RD EAGLE ID 83616-4137 1550 W FRAMCL,IN RD 1550 W FRANKLIN RD 51213223010 BUCKNER WILLIAM J & JODY ANN 2425 W VICTORY RD MERIDIAN ID 83642-6845 0 W WALTMAN LANE 51213223005 CRESTWOOD ESTATES HOMEOWNER'S PO BOX 575 MERIDIAN ID 83680-0575 0 W BARRETT DR 81608630140 JACKSON GERALD JR & DIANA L 1484 W CREST WOOD DR MERIDIAN ID 83642-2498 81608630130 ROPP BRYAN K & LISA K 1476 W CREST WOOD DR MERIDIAN ID 83642-2498 81608630120 BEEHIVE HOMES INC 445 CLEAR CREEK DR MERIDIAN ID 83642-5263 1448 W CREST WOOD DR 81608630110 ANDERST ROBERT E AND 1432 W CREST WOOD DR MERIDIAN ID 83642-2498 81608630100 WOOD RANDY & MICA 1396 W CREST WOOD DR MERIDIAN ID 83642-2400 88956000005 VANHEES LARRY ET AL PO BOX 866 MERIDIAN ID 83680-1212 119 S CINDER RD • NOTICE OF HEARING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN pursuant to the Ordinances of the City of Meridian and the Laws of the State of Idaho, that the Planning and Zoning Commission of the City of Meridian will hold a public hearing at the Meridian City Hall, 33 East Idaho Street, Meridian, Idaho, at the hour of 7:00 p.m., on September 9, 1997, for the purpose of reviewing and considering the Application of William and Lynn Martell for a Gonditional Use Permit for property located in the SW '/4 of the SW %4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the corner east of Linder Road and north of Franklin. The Application requests a Conditional Use Permit to construct a sports bar, selling beer, wine and liquor. A more particular legal description of the above property is on file in the City Clerk's office at Meridian City Hall, 33 East Idaho Street, and is available for inspection during regular business hours. A copy of the Application is available upon request. Any and all interested persons shall be heard at said public hearing and the public is welcome and invited to submit testimony. Dated this 20~' day of August, 1997. WILLIAM G. BERG, JR., CI CL RK PUBLISH August 22 and September 5, 1997. \~ W~ 1 ~ ~~ __ 40 l ~ • ~ Y J . :. ~ j ~ v. ~~ : ` ~ ~~ N ~~' I~ I ~ 4 i i 'N I _ __ ~\ ~- ~ ~.. C -_ ------ - -- - i r - I R ~~ '~ ~~ i IN ~ IM Rt r V~,~ n ~ -~' ;~~ ~ ~: ~,. ,, .~ .~. , ~. ~.. ~~i ~~~ ~ i ~ly~ V ~ 'V l~ I J ~~i~~ i r L /.t/Q1~'.q - ..~. C F ~ N N ~~ m I ~~ • J D ~ ~_ m =, -, ~ _ ~ ~ ~ \~ - I ~ s ~; ! ~ ~ ~ n ~~ ~- .r; `c- C~ ~ r 0 '~` ~ ~~ ~, ~li* _. ~,~ - --- ~ b~ i~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ J ~ I v ~+ ~.i I, -- .~~_ ~., + _~~ ~ ~, ~ . »___+ -- ,. .. ~` _ i i f; ~i ~~ ~ BRCADWCV -' /, i m 7 ~ ~ j I I I ~ 1 D ! I „~.. ;I t:; SUSAN S. EASTLAKE, President GARY E. RICHARDSON, vice President SHERRY R. HUBER, Secretary September 2, 1997 William and Lynn Martell 2241 NW 10th Street Meridian, Idaho 83642 Re: Staff Level Approval MCU-30-97 Franklin Road e/o Linder Road Sports bar Facts and Findings: ' A. The Ada County Highway District (ACRD) staff has received the above referenced application requesting conditional use approval to construct a~3,2~0-square foot,sports bar. The 0.66-acre site is located on the north side of Franklin Road appro:~unately 175-feet east of Linder Road. This development is estimated to generate 250 additional vehicle trips per day based on the Institute of Transportation Engineers Trip Generation manual. B. The application and site plan received by the City of Meridian and submitted to the District on August 21, 1997, have been reviewed by the ACHD Development Services staff and conforms to applicable District standards/policy, ~ or can be made to conform with the change(s) to the plan described in the requirements stated below. This is a staff level approval and will .not be hCard by ACHD's Commission unless the site plan is changed in such a manner as to not conform with District standards/policy or an appeal of the Development Services 'staff decision is submitted as described within the Standard Requirementsoutlined below! C. The District has`completed the design for improving Franklin Road from E. 1st Street to Linder Road to acquire the needed right-of--way for that project. The following requirements are provided as recommendations for conditions of approval to the City of Meridian: Site Specific Requirements: i . Provide a $1,164.50 deposit to the Public Rights-of--Way Trust Fund at the District for the required street improvements of approximately 137-feet of 5-foot wide concrete sidewalk on ada county highway district 318 East 37th • Boise, Idaho 83714-6499 • Phone (208) 345-7680 Franklin Road abutting the parcel, prior to District approval of the final plat or issuance of a building permit (or other required permits), whichever occurs first. 2. Provide a recorded cross access easement for the parcels to the east and west to use this parcel for access to the public streets prior to issuance of a building permit (or other required permits). The District intends to require a similar agreement of the owners of the parcels to the east and west if they are the subject of a future development application. 3. Utility street cuts in new pavement less than five years old are not allowed unless approved in writing by the District. Contact Construction Services at 345-7667 (with file number) for details . 4. Coordinate the construct of a driveway on Franklin Road with District Plans and Surveys staff. 5. Provide a $2,700.00 Deposit to the Public Right-of--Way Trust Furid to construct a 6-inch raised median in the center of Franklin Road extending from,the,-Franklin/Linder intersection to a point 270-feet east. The District will construct the median'as part of the 1998 reconstruction project. ~~ 6. Graveled driveways abutting public streets create maintenance problems due to gravel being tracked onto the roadway. Pave the driveway its full xequired width of 30 to 36-foot wide to at least 30-feet beyond the edge of pavement of Franklin Road. 7. As required by District policy, restrictions on the width, number and locations of driveways, shall be placed on future development of tlusparcel: ~` 8. Other than the access point specifically approved ~~ith this application, direct lot or parcel access to Franklin Road is prohibited. Standard Requirements: __ 1. This decision of the Development Services Supervisor may be appealed to the Ada County Highway District Commission by the applicant or by an owner of property within 300-feet of the parcel within 15 calender ,days from the date of this report. The request shall specificallX identify each requirementto`be reconsidered and include a written explanation of why such a requirement would result in a ubstantial hardship or inequitX. The request will be heard by the District Commission at an evening meeting within 20 calender days of the District's receipt of the appeal letter. The appellant will be notified of the date and time of the Commission meeting. MCU3097.SLA Page 2 2. After ACRD Commission action, any request for reconsideration of the Commission's action shall be made in writing to the Development Services Supervisor within two days of the action and shall include a minimum fee of $110.00. The request for reconsideration shall specificallX identify each requirement to be reconsidered and include written documentation of data that was not available to the Commission at the time of it's original decision. The request for reconsideration will be heard by the District Commission at the next regular meeting of the Commission. If the Commission agrees to reconsider the action, the applicant will be notified of the date and time of the Commission meeting at which the reconsideration will be heard. 3. Payment of applicable road impact fees are required prior to building construction in accordance with Ordinance #188, also known as Ada County Highway District Road Impact Fee Ordinance. 4. All design and construction shall be in accordance with the Ada County Highway District Policy Manual, ISPWC Standards and approved supplements, Construction Services procedures and all applicable ACRD Ordinances unless specificall~~waived herein. 5. The applicant shall submit revised plans for staff approval, 'pri©r to issuance of building permit (or other required permits), which incorporates an_y required design changes 6. Construction, use and property development shall be in conformance.with all applicable requirements of the Ada County Highway District prior to District approval for occupancy. 7. Any change by the applicant in the planned use of the property which is the subject of this application, shall require the applicant to comply with all rules, regulations, ordinances, plans, or other regulatory and legal restrictions in force at he .time the applicant or its successors in interest advises the Highway District`of its intent to change the planned use of the subject property unless awaiver/variance of said requirements or other legal relief is granted pursuant to the law in effect at the time the chance in use'is sought. 8. No change in the .terms and conditions of this approval shall be valid unless they are in writing and signed by he applicant or the applicant's authorized representative and an authorized representative of the Ada County .Highway District. The burden shall be upon the applicant to obtain written confirmation. of any'ehange from the Ada County Highway District. MCU3097.SLA Page 3 Conclusion of Law: 1. ACRD requirements are intended to assure that the proposed use/development will not place an undue burden on the existing vehicular and pedestrian transportation system within the vicinity impacted by the proposed development. Should you have any questions or comments, please contact the ACHD Development Services staff at 345-7662. Sincerely, Larry Sale Development Services Supervisor cc: Project file Lead agency .• MCU3097.SLA Page 4 ~~~~~ V SEP i 11,997 t~1Y OF ~,H September 11, 1997 Re: Bill & Lynn's Attention, Meridian City Counsel Due to the concerns of the citizens of Meridian we cordiality withdraw our application for a conditional use permit for the Franklin Linder location. We appreciate. the counsels time and effort and that of all the good citizens of Meridian. As members of the community, we are currently negotiating for a new site that we feel will comply with the best interest of the city of Meridian. Thank you Bill & Lynn Martell ~~ ~//~~ Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 36 Buday: We submitted that with the application, we had site plans, elevations, floor plans, building, all of that stuff was available. I would have remembered and I would have complimented you on providing that information. Smith: Irregardless of whether the elevations were submitted that is just something we need to work out with staff. Irregardless 1 would still request that you re-work the site plan. Buday: If there are any other questions it is unfortunate that you hadn't received those elevations and site plan but that was all part of the package that was supposed to have been submitted.. We brought along this color elevation it is just for viewing. Smith: Nonetheless (inaudible) we continue this to allow us to review take another crack at working out some of these things on the site. Buday: Thank you Smith: Mr. Chairman, I would like to make a motion to continue this public hearing to October 14"' and ask that the applicant redesign the site plan addressing the comments and concerns that were addressed this evening and present building elevations to the Commission and that the City Attorney prepare preliminary findings of fact and conclusions of law on this agenda item. MacCoy: Second Johnson: Discussion? I have a question, you made it sound as if they have to redesign it, was that your intent or just to look at redesign? The way your motion it doesn't leave any leeway there is no flexibility there. Smith: I will revise that one little bit to look at and work with staff on redesigning the site plan. MacCoy: Second Johnson: We have a motion and a second, all those in favor? Opposed? MOTION CARRIED: All Yea ITEM #15: PUBLIC HEARING: REQUEST FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR A BEER, WINE, AND LIQUOR SPORTS BAR BY WILLIAM & LYNN MARTELL - CORNER OF FRANKLIN AND CINDER ROADS: Johnson: At this time I will open the public hearing and I would like to give some instructions or at least hopefully they will be instructions. We have a large group tonight obviously you are ail interested in this and a lot of you will want to testify. If you follow Meridian Planning & Zo~j Commission September 9, 1997 Page 37 our sign over here our guide keep your remarks concise and I will try to limit those to three minutes. Try not to be redundant, don't repeat the same thing over and over. But if you want to echo somebody's remarks that is fine. We will move this along as quickly as possible. At this time I will open the public hearing which I have already done I guess and invite the applicant or the applicant's representative to come forward and be swum and address the Commission. William Martell, 2241 NW 10th, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney Martell: First thing I want to do is to try and get rid of these misconceptions that we are going to be similar to a Kit Kat or a JB's Sports Bar. The Sports Bar I am recommending is only for sports such as your baseball, football, basketball. Large screen t.v.'s, pool, darts, shuffle board, that is what I have now. That is what I have now, I have run a bar successfully for 6'/ years and all I want to do is expand it and move to this location. It is not going to be like a Kit Kat or a JB's and it is not on the comer it is back from the corner. That is a very bad misconception, we are located approximately 200 feet east of that comer is where our lot is supposed to be. Johnson: If you would just tell us a little bit about your building, your design that sort of thing. Martell: The building and design is probably just as you have plans of just a nice little 3200 square foot building. It is just basically going to be a place for people to come and enjoy themselves, play some games, play some darts, play some pool. Johnson: Thank you, questions of the Commissioners to the applicant? MacCoy: I do, have you read the staff report for this material? Martell: Yes MacCoy: Do you have any comments about it? Martell: I have no problems with any of it. MacCoy: You mentioned a sports bar, people (inaudible) yet you are going to sell beer, wine and liquor at your location. Martell: Yes sir that is what I do now. After 6 '/ years and I haven't had a problem with anything. MacCoy: 1 guess I have a problem from the standpoint that I know you are outside the school zone situation but I think it is vvi:h beer, wine and etc. being sold in the premises it is not a good thing. We are trying to get our kids to do a better job and I have a real Meridian Planning & Zo~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 38 problem with that. Also the location of Franklin and Linder, just a question on why did you pick that location? Martell: We picked that location because we feel that things are moving that way. There is going to be a new five lane by this time next year on that area. We picked that location because we feel things are moving that direction. That four comers is zoned commercial there is going to be some commercial there. MacCoy: Agreed there will be because that is the way it is zoned. But it is basically a residential area to the south and it is already a bad traffic intersection. I realize the five lanes will be a big help because it will be probably lighted with traffic lights. But 1 guess I have a real concern about the Gientele that will show up there and 1 don't care to read in the paper about two cars coming together at angles and we have another death on our hands. . Johnson: I don't think we are going the right direction. I think what we are doing is being philosophical here as a commission and we need to confine our remarks as a commission to the application and what is being presented. 1 am sure we will get plenty of that type of comment to follow here shortly. MacCoy: I am sure we will too, but I wanted to make sure that one you had read the staff material and you mentioned just a regular simple building. Is that going to be a wood building? Martell: Not it is going to be a block building, decorative block on the front with wood trim and wood easements on the front of it. MacCoy: What about your signage now? Martell: signage we will do whatever the Commission decides we can do there at that time. We have not planned that. MacCoy: What about, another thing that is a concern of mine is the lighting, the exterior lighting of a building like this. Martell: We will have parking lighting and exterior lighting that is required and that should be there. MacCoy: I don't want anything glaring into the actual traffic. Martell: If it is we won't put it there. We are set back quite a ways off the road. We allowed for setbacks that the 11 foot that Ada County is taking out. We are setback to the back of the lot. MacCoy: I am going to hold the rest of mine. Meridian Planning & Z~ng Commission September 9, 1997 Page 39 Smith: Again I would like to see what the building looks like that you are proposing here. I can't even quite frankly I can't even make a decision on this without knowing what the building is going to look like. You have stated it is going to be masonry decorative block on the front, what is going to be on the rest of the building? Martell: It will be a cinder block finish with a smooth finish on the exterior. We have a set of plans here don't we? Smith: I have a site plan. Martell: Oh just a site plan you don't have a set of the regular plans? Smith: I only have a site plan, it is always desirable to submit the additional information the elevations. We can't evaluate this. You are asking us to make decisions on building projects here and we have to know what they look like. Johnson: On the applicant's behalf here he has submitted what is required by our ordinance. Smith: I understand that, I am not going to belabor the point. Again siting wise from a site planning standpoint I would like to see the parking in the back and the building up front. If the building is designed properly I think that would be a more desirable frontage. Martell: I think it can be designed that way too. I don't see a problem, you can have some in front or some in back. We do have the room to do that. Smith: That is probably, what are your hours of operation? Martell: Hours of operation are 10 in the morning to 2 a.m. Smith: That is pretty much the extent of my comments then. Borup: I had one other, and that is pertaining to the staff comment number 18 about water main, apparently at least on the comments there is not a water main in Franklin Road at this time. Martell: I read that myself Keith and I am not sure, I haven't looked into it far enough to see how close that water main gets to us. Borup: I just wondered if you had addressed that or discussed that with water department or anything. Martell: We have not at this time no. Meridian Planning & Zc~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 40 Borup: Apparently they are planning on doing that when Franklin Road is constructed which brings me to the question what time frame did you have? Martell: Well our time frame is based on whenever we can get it done Keith to move into the thing. tf we have to move a little bit on that water main I sure don't want to drill a well for it. Borup: I don't think that is an option, not being in the City limits. Martell: So if we have to wait for that or if we have to get with the water department to see if we can get that done a little early we will. Borup: You said you are operating a bar presently, is that in Boise? Martell: It is right here in Meridian Borup: What is the name of it? Martell: Bill N' Lynn's Place and this will be the same place. It will still be the same place, we are not opening a new one we are just moving our existing one. Borup: I have no other questions at this time. Johnson: I have one question regarding this letter from Bruce Freckleton and Shari Stiles dated September 4, do you have that letter? Martell: I do not have a copy of that one. Borup: Those are the staff comments. Martell: I have those right here. Johnson: I just for my own edification wanted to see if that question had been resolved in number 1 specifically where it says repeated request for the applicant's representative to include the entire parcel on their site plan have been ignored. Is that, have you ever responded to that? Martell: I was not aware I will have to talk to my builder back here on that because he has been handling that, my realtor and my builder. 1 was not aware it had not been resolved. Johnson: Any other questions? Thank you very much Bill. This is a public hearing, is there anyone el ae that would like to address the Commission? Connie balling, 1388 W. Crestwood Drive, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Meridian Planning & Zo~ Commission September 9, 1997 Page 41 Dalling; I received this notice in the mail, it only was sent to 3 residents in our subdivision because it only has to go within 300 feet of where this property is to go. So people were kind enough to photo copy it and send it on. When I first read it I was concerned about it just personally I did not want to have my kids pass a bar on their way to and from school every day plus lunch. So I started talking to a few of the people, there was many people that lived within a mile of me that had not even heard about this notice. They did not receive anything in the mail and I understand that by City requirements you do not have to notify everybody around. So I asked, I photo copied 400 copies myself and passed them out to some of my friends and asked them to help me with a petition to let people know that we are not interested in having a bar besides our residence. I was amazed with the overwhelming response I got when I was out getting petitions. I didn't even have to finish speaking before people said give me the petition and let me sign it. I didn't even have to finish telling them about it. I have over 667 names here, I would like to submit to let you know these people are all I believe within a mile vicinity all around this location. To let you know that we do not want a bar built on that corner. We understand that it is commercial but we do not want it to be a bar. I would also tike to have a photo copy of this. Johnson: Yes you have to leave that with us since you are entering it as evidence. You don't have a copy of it? Dalling: I didn't make copies I didn't know I needed them. Johnson: Well maybe you can talk Will into doing it but it is $.10 a sheet. Dalling: The main thing t wanted to say is with less than 6 months ago there was a big rally in Boise with the Enough is Enough program. I did not go to it myself but all of the students from Meridian High School were sent to it and these kids were told no drinking. They didn't say a little bit, they didn't say in a nice bar go ahead and do it. They said no drinking, enough is enough. That is my main concern, is where do you stand is enough enough? I do not frequent the bars in Meridian but right off the top of my head I can name nine. Where are the places for these young people to go and have some recreation. Where does Meridian have for us as families to go and have recreation. This town needs to start providing more places for families and for the youth to be able to stay here in Meridian and not have to go to Boise for entertainment and recreation. We have one City park and I would like to see us be able to get more parks. We could use another swimming pool. Kids that go down there have to just bob up and down to enjoy the water. I understand that the City does not make a whole lot of money off of City parks but I think that is something that is better spent to do something like that then to put a bar in. One other thing while we were doing the petition the lady that owns the property on the northwest comer of Linder and Franklin wrote this letter, she could not be here tonight but she wanted me to submit it to let you know that she is not in favor of it either. Meridian Planning & Zo~ Commission September 9, 1997 Page 42 Johnson: Thank you, any questions from the Commission? Thank you very much Ehno Tiddens, 213 E. 2"d Street, Meridian, was swum by the City Attorney. Tiddens: I am 70 years old, retired, I live by myself. About twice a week I either walk or drive to Bill N' Lynn's from my house. On the way I pass two bars that are owned by people that do not live in Meridian. That is the main reason I go to Bill and Lynn's he is very proud to live in Meridian. It is real nice to go there especially just to be around people. 1 meet some of my other senior friends there and we discuss the current events and I like, I don't have cable t.v. that gives me a chance to watch the Seattle Seahawks and the Seattle Mariners play once in a while. Like Bill says people just have a lot of fun there. What he means there but fun I believe is that people have their birthday parties there, people have their 40~' anniversary parties there. We have super bowl game parties, all of that nature and Bill and Lynn are always very generous in furnishing food for a free buffet so everybody can eat as well as drink. I do believe, I don't see where his bar business would be any more objectionable as far as noise and lighting especially being set back from the road like that. 1 don't see how you could object to that any more you could a Circle K or other types of business. And 1 believe this way too that if some other business is authorized to go into that location in place of Bill N' Lynn's I think it is very discriminatory. Thank you Johnson: Thank you, any questions of Mr. Tiddens? Borup: I do Mr. Chairman, is it you say you go there a lot now. Tiddens: I go there about twice a week on the average. Borup: Is it getting pretty crowded there, is there not enough room? Tiddens: He does a very good business, it gets crowded at times yes. Borup: At times, do you feel a new location is a better place for you to go? Tiddens: Well yes, I am glad you asked that. By making Franklin Road to five lanes I understand they are going to put curb and sidewalks along that too. That will make it a lot easier and safer walking for me to go there. It is about the same distance as the other place. Borup: That is all I had. Smith: I am just confused, was the opportunity to watch the Seahawks a testimonial for or against this? Never mind Johnson: Anyone else? Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 43 Renee Jones, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attomey. (End of Tape) Jones: I would like to voice my opposition to the use of the NE quadrant of Franklin and Linder for a bar. My opposition is so strong in fact that my husband is attending a school open house this evening and I am here. The contiguous area most particularly the immediate north, southeast and southwest quadrants is single family residential use with a high population of school aged children. My subdivision alone which is in the southeast quadrant has three school buses transporting kindergarten and elementary children not to mention the middle and high school population. In the nearly five years I have lived in my home I have witnessed extreme traffic abuses and infractions and sadly even road rage in my subdivision and along Franklin and Linder roads. It is my believe that allowing a bar to be built on the requested site would not only increase such difficulties but encourage them. I have a five year old daughter just entering the school system and while she is of an age where she is always supervised as she ages and her boundaries expand I don't wish to see her or any other child unnecessarily exposed to the dangers that would arise from a bar in our neighbofiood. In the future I do not want to deny my daughter biking to a friends house because she would need to pass a bar which in itself increases traffic, disrupts traffic flow and increases traffic violations and negligence due to perhaps intoxication. I don't not wish her to be subjected to any potential deviant behavior from those gathered outside the bar. While 1 am not opposed to bars per se I am opposed to their location within a residentially populated area particularly given the hours of operation. Let Bill and Lynn's stay at their current location. In short I do not want to see approval of this use. Johnson: Thank you, any questions? Alan Hochstrasser Jr., 1010 Pennwood Street, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Hochstrasser: In 1991 my wife and I were married and we moved to Meridian. I am a graduate even though I have a baby face of Meridian High over 11 years ago. I have seen Meridian go through a lot of changes and this not a written speech so I apologize if it is somewhat haphazard. But 1 do want you guys to know I know how hard your job is. 1 am really proud of the effort you have maintained. I am not opposed per se to a person building a bar but I cannot support this particular location. I live in Fenway Park, my wife and I have raised a family since 1991. We have two kids, one living and one deceased and I have to tell you right now. 1 cannot feel comfortable having a bar particularly one that is supposedly a sports bar. 1 would like to just point out one thing that I hope is helpful to the Commissioners. That is for a sports bar and I am really tired of hearing ~a respectable sports bar. To me a bar is not a synonym for respectable necessarily, now that doesn't mean that it necessarily any bar is bad or shouldn't be located. But it is-not one that generally promotes responsibility. It is not one that generally especially with the hours until 2 am in the morning promotes good common sense. Now I know we Meridian Planning & Zo~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 44 can't say that 2 drinks equal a drunk driver all we know that the more alcohol that is consumed the more tired and fatigue that a body has the poorer your judgement becomes. Now when we want to talk about it being a respectable sports bar to me that feels like it is somewhat of a fagade. First and foremost if it is a sports bar with large screen tv's, shuffle board, darts, and pool tables all crammed into a 3200 square foot facility. I have a hard time picturing that. I Know that dart boards are generally found in bars. I have a hard time, I sell t.v's for a living figuring out how many tv's can be in there and still have the functionality of a working bar. The other thing is if it is open until 2 am I don't care how badly the Seahawks are doing they will not be playing at 2 am. What will be going on there? Well the Martell's certainly hope that it is a lot of drinking, that does not promote responsibility and I have a hard time seeing that. Also just because there is a dart board in there if I have a bible and a Koran that doesn't make it amulti-cultural religious center. It does not, it is a bar let's call it plain and simple, it is a bar. My parents live in Eagle and they have been raised in Eagle or I have been raised in Eagle with the exception of getting married and moving to Meridian. When I go to visit my parents and there have been times for my parents health that I had to go to Eagle. How do I get to Eagle, think about it you take Franklin Road and you pass several bars before you get to Eagle, well can't do that. If it is in the middle of the night I can't feel safe going at 2 am (inaudible) a person that has obviously been drinking for quite a few hours. So what else do I take, the only route I have that I can feel safe is Linder Road. The same one that my son when he attends Meridian High School will have to pass by after a school dance. I am sorry I don't mean to sound like an overbearing father or anything like that but when I moved into that area it was very specifically to raise a family. If this was allowed and was passed I would have to look elsewhere other than Meridian. That is all I have to say. Johnson: Thank you, questions? Smith: What is a sports bar in your definition? Hochstrasser: A sports bar would be comparable to the Ram, are you familiar with that. Smith: Yes Hochstrasser: They are capable of maintaining a large number of people and have a large, would you agree that it is over 3200 square feet. I think the bar is larger than 3200 square feet practically. 3200 square foot I am currently remodeling or looking at remodeling in our business to 4000 square foot area. 1 cannot imagine that being anything else but a bar. Johnson: How about amini-sports bar? Hochstrasser: With the promoting of drinking I would say possibly not the promotion of sports. Meridian Planning & Zo~ Commission September 9, 1997 Page 45 Johnson: Okay Kevin Dickey, 958 W. Waltman Drive, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Dickey: I certainly appreciate being able to voice my opinion regarding this sports bar. To be brief Meridian I guess you would say is also known as the Hub of the Treasure Valley. Particularly with respect to the Franklin Road that passes through our City. When entering Meridian from Boise we pass several bars. We pass JB's Sport's Bar, we pass the Farmers Club, we pass other places such as the tobacco connection coming from the Nampa way we pass the Kit Kat club. And this is all located on Franklin Road where I live. I wonder what kind of image we are portraying as to what direction Meridian is headed. That leaves me in question as what to our community especially that region is going to become. Also one other comment that I would like to make. I believe that there is a place for these types of businesses, the Martell's are good people and they certainly deserve to be able to operate a place that if they choose. But that location is just not the best place. The Martell's do not have control over who comes and goes from that establishment. They do not have control over what condition they arrive and what condition they leave. Today it is a sports bar, whatever a sports bar has been defined to be. But tomorrow what else could it be. I seriously question the issue has been brought up many times tonight about its location in relation to our schools. Is that the best place to have it so close to an institution of teaming where our tomorrov-rs future goes to become what we hope them to be. Again I would just like to say that I am in opposition to this sports bar and that is all I have to say. Johnson: Thank you Cherie Pearson, 1369 W. Kimra, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attomey. Pearson: I would also like to express opposition. I am a stay home mom and I work part time. Some of our best friends live right by Meridian High School. So I have a 2 and a 3 year old that both can ride bikes and we ride bikes up Linder Road now almost every day. If there is a bar there I am not going to let me kids ride right by there worrying about who is pulling and who is pulling out of there. I know that when we bought our house there there were farms and that is why we go for bike rides there because we can pull right up to the corner and see the horses that are there. We can go down one block and watch the cows eat. That is why we moved to Meridian to be out by, right on the edge of farms there is no housing past Linder Road for quite a ways. That is why we moved out there. I am opposed to it, I worked at a bar when I was in college and I have walked by their bar before not that it is a good or bad place but people are going there for the sole purpose of drinking. If it is a sports bar which I think they think that sounds better to me that is not any better. A sports bar they are coming to watch games so obviously you have cowboys and 49'er fans so no matter who loses there are people leaving there angry and the fact to add in the alcohol. So now there is more abuse on Superbowl Sunday than any other time. So add in the alcohol and the fact that they were there watching a sports game. So someone had to win someone had to lose so Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 46 now they are leaving this bar in what kind of mood they are in. I just don't want that by my neighborhood. There aren't speed bumps in our neighborhood because we have beehive homes, elderly assisted living homes. That is fine I don't worry about the speed right now, but let's say there is a cop on Franklin Road if you are going to avoid it you are going to come through the neighborhoods that are right there and you are going to pass right by my house. If my kids are out and go across the street from neighbors I don't want somebody screaming through our neighborhood or even driving through there intoxicated. I can't control how my neighbors come home now but hopefully I know enough of them and we all have enough respect for each other that we respect when are kids are out there and what it going on. I am definitely opposed to it, I know there is a time and a place for bars and I think the time has gone. Now we are all talking about our kids and not drinking and not driving. We .had this huge thing here Enough is Enough and 1 think contributing to a bar, putting it right by the high school right by residential is just not the place. Where they are now in a commercially zoned area for that where they are by restaurants f think that is an appropriate place and they can stay where they are at. Kevin Abbott, 1284 W. Crestwood Drive, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Abbott: Good evening gentlemen, I am here has a board member of Crestwood Estates No. 3, 4 and 5. That is the area of subdivision closes to that corner. Within our homeowners associations 3 out of 5 is majority rules. I have at least three I have not been able to contact the two against this bar. I agree wholeheartedly with what everyone else has said about the children issues and other issues. But I want to bring up a couple more issues. I want to look at the liability of us as homeowners, my backyard looks onto Franklin Road, what are the increased chances of a drunk driver coming through my back fence leaving and me being responsible for it. We all know that there was a house on up Franklin Road that had a fence torn out from somebody (inaudible). 1 am not sure about the liabilities of my insurance but even with a deductible that can be costly. Secondly, we own the RV's stores rigr~t there on the corner. I know for a fact that if someone were to hit into our RV stores we do not have insurance to coverage that. We would have to pay for that out of our pocket and I am opposed to that. I am also concerned about the property values. Let's face it would you guys want a bar in your backyard. I know #here are going to have to be some commercial buildings back there I knew that. I have a butcher shop in my backyard right now. I don't care about that, that doesn't bother me. I have a flashing light in my backyard, I am really concerned about the lighting that is big issue. But more than that I am thinking if there is a bar there would you want your business next to a bar. I am thinking of what commercial is going to come in there in the future and the other areas around it. There is a corner on our comer that is also commercial area that Bill Buckner owns. I am sure that is an issue to him. That is my area of concern, I do kudo what the other people say about the children, I have the same issues but I don't want to be redundant. Johnson: Thank you Meridian Planning & Zog Commission September 9, 1997 Page 47 Gwen Pugh, 1944 N. Hilmont Avenue, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Pugh: I am for the bar, 1 have lived in Meridian off and on for the last 20 years. I don't drink, I don't smoke, that probably sounds weird going into a bar. Bill N'Lynn's is a home town bar, it is a cheers type bar. Nice people, I have been going in there for 5 of the 6 years they have been own. I haven't witnessed a lot of drunken driving or raucous behavior out in the parking lot. There is already a bar on Franklin within a mile of this subdivision. As far as the increase in traffic from what I understand there is a proposal for an alt night convenience store on that corner that will also sell beer and wine. I live but a block from Maverick Store and there are a lot of children that hang out there and nobody seems to be real concerned about that. Maybe people have never seen the fact that people by beer and sit in the parking lot ,sit behind the stores. That is commercially zoned on Franklin so there are going to be businesses going in there. Growth is going to increase the traffic there, it is inevitable there is no way around that. Bill and Lynn's existing place has commercial businesses around them all over, they have pizza places they have realty offices, they have Mexican food stores, I am sure there is going to be plenty of growth around there. As far as the proposed building being large enough the existing building that Bill and Lynn's has is 2200 square feet. They have a large screen t.v. two small t.v.'s mounted on the ceiling. They have two pool tables, three dart boards, 1 video golf game, that is what I like to play, one shuffle board and one really nicely set up kareoke system. And I also like to sing so I kareoke in there. We don't have a lot of wild parties and obnoxious people. Again it is inevitable for growth and if you in raising your children can't be prepared for the growth. I have a letter here also from Brad Michelson, and I would like to read it to you to. "To whom this issue concerns, I fully support Bill and Lynn's lounge in their move to improve business and the internal environment. Bill and Lynn the owners support Meridian and surrounding community through Chamber of Commerce events. Sponsorships of community athletic teams. Both adult and children, Meridian fire department fund, fundraising events along with many other beneficial concerns. I am employed in the Emergency Services field and know that very few calls for Meridian police, fire or paramedics are needed to handle belligerent events persons due to the professional and (inaudible). I am the parent of a two year old and a an eight year old. That I firmly believe and have instructed if they have or see an emergency they can or should asked assistance from the quality personnel and friendly patrols of Bilt and Lynn's I frequently and enjoyably patron this lounge and hope to continue so I request to denounce any objections to Bill and Lynn's objection to Bill & Lynn's new building and further community support progression. Thanks Brad Michelson" Thank you gentlemen. Tom Roam, 115 South Linder, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Roam: I also grew up in Meridian, went to high school here. I have seen the changes and some of them I like and some of them I don't. My concern is not so much the growth is I lived next to a bar. I moved back to Meridian because I vranted to get away from it. They moved a bar in next to my old house and I don't know maybe a lot of you here haven't had that experience or that enjoyment. I have and not it is not any fun Meridian Planning & Zo~j Commission September 9, 1997 Page 48 having a bar in your back yard. I would come home to people peeing in my garage door, women peeing on my garage door, I found rubbers on the ground, Kotex on the ground and people screwing in the front of my house, no offense and I don't mean to be rude here but what goes on in the parking lot is a huge concern to me. I am probably one of the closest homes to this bar. I am not used to coming down to these meetings but I figured on this one I had to. I do not want to be next to a bar, I moved back to meridian 2 '/ years ago to get away from it and I am not about to do it again. What goes on and things that 1 saw here would disgust anyone of you sitting here. If you want that in your yard then you put that bar in there put it in your yard. (Inaudible) even the people at the bar would not want that in their back yard. You can't I have two girls and I would come home and there would be people screwing right there in my driveway. Its like sorry girls look away, what is that on the ground, sorry you can't see that let me kick it aside. Cups were constantly blowing in I was constantly picking up the mess. They said well this is a nice bar, this is a clean bar. That is great you cannot control the people, you may want to sell it. That is what business is, you build and sell them. Then what about the next person, you can't control that, this is residential and you don't need that in this neighborhood. Johnson: I have a question Smith: I am just curious what bar you lived next to Roam: You know where Banbury is, the Seven Mile there, the when I moved in it was not a bar. Then they went back to a bar. Johnson: How far is your personal residence from this location? Roam: Just at 300 feet, south on the other side. (Inaudible) Roam: I am not in the subdivision I am just living (inaudible) Johnson: Okay, I appreciate some of your comments. Cortland Wacker, 1300 S. Heidi Place, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Walker: I think most of the people that live south of the freeway that have kids going to Meridian High School probably did not even hear about this meeting. I live right across, the neighborhood right across the street from Franklin but my children, I have my 5~' child in Meridian high school now. Most of their friends have been south of the freeway over the years. Just to represent them I would guess that probably close to 50% of the younc people that go to Meridian high school come from thy: south side of the freeway. That is their main route right out Franklin Road. They come across the freeway there, come out Franklin Road turn right there at Linder and you come right down there to the Meridian Planning & Zo~ Commission September 9, 1997 Page 49 high school. A few will go out Meridian Road and come out Pine but I will be most of them come out Franklin Road. With ball games going on Friday nights and Saturday nights and different activities I think it would be a real mistake for that to be allowed when we have that kind of traffic on the road along with our youth on week nights and week ends as well with different activities. Sally Lambson, 349 S. Lodestone, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Lambson: I am a parent, I am also an educator here in this district, I teach right here at Meridian elementary. Our school boundaries will encompass that corner so I have the kids that come from the homes that live in this area. I also have a child who attends Meridian elementary and 1 have child who now attends the high school. I have about 4 points the reason we should have this bar here. One we just put the stadium in at the high school. So we just brought all the kids back to Meridian so that they were safe and now we are going to put a bar in their path. On a Friday night we all know we have got 15 year old drivers shouldn't be driving at night but how do wee know we have got 16 year old drivers on a Friday night excited about winning the game and we are going past the bar. I don't know that is a combination we want. Second the bar will become a very popular place because it is right on the road to the Idaho Center, the activity center out there. High traffic area once this gets built. Already a concert is out, if anybody has been at the comer of Linder and Franklin when one of the concerts or something has been out it is the second route that people are taking instead of going down the freeway. It is high traffic already and we want to put a bar at that comer for people to pop into right then. A sports bar until 2 in the morning, I don't know that seems a little questionable that we are going to have the relationship on that. Third the enough is enough issue. I as an educator know a lot of these kids in the home are coming from we do not need to plant a bar in the middle of this. We need to fight for these kids and this is not how you are going to do it. Vince Earnhart, 1418 Organzer, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Eamhart: Mr. Chairman and members of the Commission. Perhaps I can save us a little time tonight. I would like to do something here that may be a little different. How many in the audience know me personally raise your hand. I think I can safely speak for these people if they will allow me to do so. How many of those that raised your hand will allow me to speak for you? There is guarantee they won't talk. My wife and I prepared a tittle letter and at the concern of being redundant with what Mrs. balling has said and what Mr. Jones has said and . Mr. Hochstrasser has said, Mr. Dickey, Mrs. Pearson, Mr. Abbott, Mr. Walker, Mrs. Lambson and even what Mr. Roam said I will try not to be redundant with what his comments were. Although I in principle agree with them immensely. Let me give you a copy of the letter that I will extract most of my comments from. This proposed location is extremely close to residential areas where there are many small children and families who would be in harms way from the influences of a business that has no business being close to a residential area. There are no alternate routes out of the neighbofioods to the south of the proposed location. Meridian Planning & Z~Ig Commission September 9, 1997 Page 50 This comer is the only logical ingress and egress for vehicle traffic for approximately 300 homes and several subdivisions. Residents would have no choice in passing by this proposed bar. .Students walking south on Linder from Meridian High school must pass by the proposed location. From the rail road tracks south to Crestwood there are no sidewalks for foot traffic. Linder is very narrow for this %4 mile and students and others are in danger even with sober, alert drivers due to the heavy flow of traffic coming from the school. Not only from school time but also from extracurricular activities as well. We shudder to think of the increased danger to pedestrian traffic of any of the drivers if any of the other drivers reflexes were impaired by alcohol. We purchased our home about five years ago not realizing that a sports bar may be built close to our property. This will have a dramatic effect on the property values for all of the homes I the surrounding neighborhoods. Had we known of the possibility of constructing a sports bar at the time we bought we possibly would not have bought in Mallard landing. Some questions loomed because of the considerations we have here. Have environmental impact studies been done to determine the impact that a sports bar will have on our neighborhoods. Have you looked at the potential risks to our neighborhood children changes in crime rates, accident rates, number of citations issued, value of property and so forth that come about from the addition of undesirable elements. Does Meridian want to develop the reputation that Garden City has worked so diligently to alter for the better. As you can see we are extremely concerned about this proposal and heartedly endorse not granting a permit for the construction of a sports bar. Johnson: Thank you Kristen Miller, 1491 W. Crestwood, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Miller: Besides the fact that I agree with most everything that was stated tonight I know that most people brought up that the comer is commercial and I am aware of that. Going out on our front step that is what we see is we see the corner of Franklin and Linder. The traffic is horrendous, besides that I worry about Meridian and the road of Franklin. Everybody stated that there is a bar Kit Kat, 2 miles away from us the other direction, we have the other bar closer to Meridian. t can't see a third bar in the same location. With all of us residential people living when you have 5 or 6 different subdivisions with all of us family oriented. I hoped when we bought this house 3 years ago that the type of businesses would be doctors, maybe a lawyers office. Reputable family facilities in this corner that I can be proud of and that my kids can be proud of. My kids are young enough now that I don't have to worry about walking to school. But if the bar goes in there I will be out of there as quick as I can because I worry about my kids having to go to school. I have a four year old and a two year old and I have to be out there early in the morning all the way through 7:00 at night because of the traffic going through our subdivision. 5:00 short cut is our road, Crestwood, everybody cuts through our subdivision I can't imagine what it would be like with additional traffic on that corner. That is all I have to say. Johnson: Thank you Meridian Planning & Zd~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 51 Tom Briggs, 360 S. Outfield Way, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Briggs: I have just a couple of quick points. The first one was 1 believe it was Mr. Smith who talked about the transitional zoning. I got the impression that you had some question as to the appropriateness of a storage facility going in next to residences. I personally and I think a lot of people would agree with me I would rather have a storage facility next to me than a new bar. On a little different topic I can speak from my own experience I was a law enforcement officer in the area. I hate to give away one of our best kept secrets but Franklin Road is a good fishing area for DUI's, it is mainly because it is the main access from Boise to the Caldwell area. You can go straight through, you can hit a whole slew of bars. Adding one to it is not going to help that problem. Donna May, 110 N. Linder Road, Meridian, was swum by the City Attorney. May: My property is the first house north of the corner of Franklin and Linder. So we are next door to this property. Some of them have said before what is that going to do to our property value. 1 don't want a bar in our neighborhood, I don't want live next to a bar. It might be a sports bar but they drink there. That man cannot have any control over those people when they leave that people. I don't want the noise at 2 o'clock in the morning, I don't want fights in the parking lot, I don't want drunks out on the road, I don't want somebody coming to my house because I am the closest to want to use the phone at 2 o'clock in the morning because they need a ride or their car wron't start or whatever. My grandchildren come to my house I don't want that kind of atmosphere for them. We are close to retirement, we have lived there for 22 years. We don't want to move but that is exactly what we will do if a bar is put in on that corner because we will not live next to a bar. We are a Christian family and we don't believe in bars in the first place. If the rest of them do that is fine let them have it somewhere else. Let them stay in Meridian where they are at now but we don't need a bar there with all of the children around there and the traffic. That is all. Johnson: Thank you Bert Peterson, 4131 W. Lamont, Meridian, was swum by the City Attorney. Peterson: I have been a resident of Meridian on and off for about 20 years. I have heard a lot of discussion about increased traffic and a lot of the comments have said that there is already incredible traffic around that area because of the subdivisions. I can remember there was a lady that spoke earlier about being able to go up and watch the horses and the cows. I can remember when Meridian was a lot like that and there are a lot of subdivisions and a lot of traffic generated by that but I don't think anybody wants to say that they don't have a right to live there. They don't have a right to build there. This is a commercial zoned area, there is going to be increased traffic with the five lane road. People had made comments about the kind of people who are going to be clientele at this bar. The people who are Bill and Lynn's current clientele and will Meridian Planning & Zc~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 52 continue to be so wherever their location is the people who built their houses repair their appliances, build their roads, represent them in court, treat their children when they are sick. These are professional people, they are working people. They are good law abiding people and Bill runs the kind of a bar where he doesn't tolerate the rowdiness etc. that everybody has expressed such concem about. And that the traffic is going to increase no matter what. If there is already a problem with traffic or with drunk drivers on the road people aren't getting home from the bars that exist now other than driving on those same streets. So if your concern is with drunk drivers or traffic then those concerns need to be addressed to the highway district and law enforcement. I know that Bill and Lynn run and excellent establishment. They don't tolerate rowdiness, they deal with problems before they start. 1 think that if you do approve their request to build this bar there the community is going to find out that they are going to be a good member of the community. They contribute a lot to charities, the generate a lot of good will in the community and they support a lot of the various fire department, law enforcement and other charity organizations and processes that go on. 1 just think that people are worried about a lot of things that don't have a lot to do with Bill and Lynn opening a bar there. Laurie Durrant, 1038 W. Greenhead, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Durrant: This gentleman that just spoke I am sure he feels that Bill and Lynn are very good people. However one person brought out also that is no guarantee those people will be running that bar five years down the road, ten years down the road. It is just no guarantee to us as homeowners that these people these fine people will be running this establishment. I am sure the people on Black Cat would feel the same. I also want to point out that a sports bar is no different than a regular bar. There was a tragedy in Boise about a week ago I believe the gentleman that left that was involved in that tragedy was coming from a sports bar. Now you can't tell me that he can pick which customers he is going to serve and which he is not. When he increases the capacity of that building there are going to be several new customers that he has never seen before. We don't want a tragedy happening in the neighborhoods of somebody smashing into a home or a car load full of a family. I just don't feel like residential neighborhoods and sports bars or bars whatever mix that .well. I think it would be irresponsible for us to allow it to happen. That is all I have. Gil Koga, 2095 Waltman Street, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Koga: Just a real quick comment, I have been standing back there for three hours so I thought I would at least say something. First of all I came up with a definition for a sports bar, a bar is a bar is a bar like a rose is a rose is a rose. I can put a kareoke name in front of it, sports in front of it, burlesque in front all it does is serves different kinds of people but it still ends up a bar is a bar is a bar. After 2 o'clock in the morning, I live sports I watch sports 10 o'clock at night I am done. t have been at bars where I gather with my friends and enjoy their camaraderie be a family if you will and have a good time. But a bar is a bar is a bar. I drink, (inaudible) I am not ashamed to say those Meridian Planning & Zc~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 53 things now to the public but anyway. All I want to say is you all have a very difficult job and I don't envy the job you have. There are a lot of emotions-here tonight and as Mr. Johnson has said earlier a lot of philosophical ideas. Mr. Martell and his customers have their feelings and the homeowners have their feelings. I just, I know it is set up legally that it is zoned commercial. I don't know the law that well to know how much philosophical ideas or emotions play into your decision. I hope and I really do that you can find some way circumvent the law if you will, go to court if you have to. But at least listen to the emotions of the people. They don't want a bar there, do some planning for the future. Let's not go there and say back in 97 is when they passed this law, you guys pay for it now but don't blame us, blame the people in 97 for making it. That is all I ask, that is all I have to say. Johnson: Maybe it is time I on the heels of Gil's comments there tell you what our real function is here. That is one of gathering information, we want all your testimony we want all your comments we want your philosophical feelings about commercial development in general specifically this application. But we don't make the final decision for approval. What we do is gather that information and send it on to the City Council. And those political people that get paid to take your views not volunteers like us you know they make the final decision on the bar. So you will have another opportunity as well in a public hearing in case you don't know the procedure with the City Council. It happens all over again, this is usually the meeting where we get the most attendance is the first notice of this sort of thing. A lot of people can only take one night like this and spend it. So we do appreciate your comments. Fitzgerald: Just one comment in terms of the public hearing, this is the only public hearing on this because it is a commercial use. Johnson: Okay Floyd Robinson, 828 Redhead Avenue, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Robinson: I understand the laws today when a group of people get together and plan something that is illegal. Whether you are a person who actually takes actually does the legal things. Hypothetically if four or five people get together and they plan a bank robbery but only two people go into the bank with guns that all five are guilty. And I feel personally that if the board was to pass this and something happened in the future that the board would be just as guilty for passing it. Thank you (END OF TAPE) Ken Sorrells, 5231 Grover, Boise, was sworn by the City Attomey. Sorrells: For the past three years my office is right next door to Bill N' Lynn's, ReMax. We have thrown a street dance for the City of Meridian for the last three years. We have not had one problem, it has all been family oriented. Little kids out there dancing having Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 54 a great time, no drunks no problems, it has all been family and we put it on that way. It was free to the public. We are having a lot of the opposition saying they are walking their kids or riding their bikes down Franklin. Well that is going to be five lanes so I think they ought to think about that and not be doing that here shortly. I guess all I can say is enough is enough. Buster Schelekeway, 1200 West Franklin, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attomey. Schelekeway: We own the 33 acres on the north side of the road next to where they are going to build. Personally I have seen all the high school kids drive by there and stop even if you make it five lanes I don't think it is any place for a bar. Johnson: Thank you I appreciate the brevity of your remarks. Brian Curry, 1058 West Louisville Court, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Curry: Gentlemen, I work with a company that has been working on building a building here. It has been a three year project, you are all aware that it takes a lot of work to get anything established and gone through the steps that you have set up to accomplish the goals that you have pre-determined that Meridian should be. Mr. Martell is about to go through that process too, he will learn that it is an arduous process, it is a lot of work. You guys make it really hard on people but I think the results show it. Things look nice, things function well, values are high, people want to come to Meridian. They don't want to go to Boise which I know sometimes in these chambers is a dirty word. But there is a reason we are coming here it is for what we are getting. There was a gentlemen in here earlier Mr. Roam I believe, he was very vocal in the things that had been displayed on his property. Gentlemen I lived 1000 feet from a bar and I saw the same exact thing. He is not a one time case, it was not here in Meridian but a bar is a bar is a bar, I don't care where you live. In fact I could even add many more things to that list that he did not explain at that time. But I do not think it would be appropriate especially with children here. The activity takes place I don't care where you live. There are a few points t would just like to cover. In the time that we lived next to that bar, it was on a busy street in fact it was on a highway, in fact it was a five lane highway. The bar sat on a comer, they had enough problems with it they finally shut the bar down, accidents dropped 40%. TrafFic matters. Another point, as I listen to the gentlemen talking outside Mr. Martell and associates the one thing that they all said in common as they were talking about what issues were going to be coming up in this meeting they were trying to persuade people in their favor, which is more power to them that is what they should do. But as they sat there and talked about those things that they wanted to get across to those people one of the things that was brought up was the best people in the world, meaning each one of you, I, or anybody else. The best people in the world get a few drinks under their belt and they tum into idiots. You have seen it, I have seen it we know it happens. Now you are putting a bar in a residential neighborhood property commercial or not. I think we has homeowners accept the fact that it is commercial property. We do look forward to some commercial development there. There is not a Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 55 one of us that wouldn't welcome some commercial development there because most of the time it benefits us. This type of operation does not benefit us. The issue has been maintained or has been expressed several times even by Mr. MacCoy 1 believe. The concern of children and the proximity of where they are going to be. I echo your comments before the meeting was changed to a different direction they are correct. We are going to have children by here all of the time. It is not a one time thing it is not every now and then, it is twice a day every day, school buses. We have already had accidents there just in school buses, you are going to add alcohol to the mix, something wrong with that. We have also heard that there is going to be in that commercial property or zoning that has taken place there are going to be several buildings. One of which is probably going to be a 7-11 or Maverick or something of that type of commercial establishment. It is said that was going to be next to the bar. We have heard from the other people who want this bar that there are kids that hang around there they can buy and adults buy beer or whatever. The kids hang around there all of the time. You want them hanging out next to a bar? Because remember the activities that have been displayed at those types of places, I have seen it the gentleman Mr. Roam has seen it. As that Cherry Lane increases to five lanes, excuse me when Cherry Lane was expanded to five lanes it is now become a traffic problem. It is one of the busiest streets in Meridian as the police department will establish and one of the ones that we have problems with traffic violations on. We are not going to expand Franklin to the same thing five lanes. I don't think anybody here argues the fact that Franklin needs to be expanded to five lanes because of the huge amount of traffic it carries. You are going to add alcohol to that mix? There is a problem with that. There is one other issue that has to do with this especially with you gentlemen in your positions. We have put faith and trust in you. We expect you to make the right decisions and as far as we are concerned most of the time you do. Most of the time we are pleased with what you do. Just remember that this decision the first time someone is one of the one people that may ever drink and drive pulls out on that road and is hit and somebody is killed that decision is on your heads. Please think carefully before you make your decision. That is all I have to say. Johnson: Okay, #hanks. Robert Knerr, 4762 Tumbleweed Place, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Knerr: Simply put from what I have been hearing tonight from these testimonials. All of the problems that are supposedly coming with this bar are already here. That is it. Johnson: Thank you John Evans, 4610 W. Franklin Road, Meridian, was sworn by the city Attorney. Evans: For the 26 years I have lived within a block of the Black Cat and Franklir. intersection where we have two bars at this time. The nature of those bars has changed a great deal since 1 have moved there. When I moved there they were quiet little Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 56 farmers places with as many tractors parked in front as anything. During that time we have witnessed I believe 6 murders, I haven't personally witnessed them they happened at those two bars. Several beatings, knittngs, shootings. We have had gun fights out in their parking lot, our house is well within range of bullets. My son when he was a small child went down there and came home with a bloody knife one day. That type of thing some of it to some degree is inevitable with any kind of bar. Even though a sports bar may be a quiet place where you have quiet people sooner or later somebody is not going to fit the profile of the regular customer or the profile of the bar will change to something that it wasn't or it isn't now. I think for those reasons and the heavy traffic there we should not allow this conditional use permit. Thank you Jerry Nicholson, 1307 W. Kimra, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Nicholson: I was one of those idiots that drank and drove and as a result I broke my neck in a car accident some 23 years ago and I have lived in this wheelchair since then and will the rest of my life. I am a little bit confused about the logic of building. You have to drive to get to one and you have to drive to leave. Isn't that in some legalizing drunk driving or it is designing a way for someone to break the law. What gets me is radar detectors. Why do we allow radar detectors, they are designed to break the law. Building a bar is designing a way for someone to break the law. Besides all the other comments that have been great it only takes one or two drinks to have an accident for someone's life to be changed dramatically. Princess Diana this last week, driving and drinking don't mix and don't believe bars should be allowed. That is all I have to say. Mark Holdaway, 1150 W. Greenhead St., Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Holdaway: Gentlemen, I am here tonight with my son, we have encouraged some our young men to come who are boy scouts so they can earn some of their merit badge requirements. My son is also here because he has very strong emotions about his issue tonight. He has been begging me all night long to put up his hand and come up here and talk to you. For the record gentlemen my son and I are opposed to this and we echo the opposition tonight. Johnson: Thank you Mark Boschulte, 1337 W. Crestwood Drive, Meridian, was swum by the City Attorney. Boschulte: A couple of things I haven't heard addressed. The size of the building was addressed, I haven't heard anything about the seating capacity of the building as far as how many constituents wilt fit in there, the number of parking spaces. That would give you an ideal of how many people will be frequenting or patronizing the bar. We have all mentioned the traffic issue. The one thing that hasn't been mentioned as far as traffic is thA traffic that will be around at 2 o'clock in the morning. If there weren't people there at 2 o'clock in the morning they wouldn't be planning the hours until 2 o'clock in the morning. Where I live on Crestwood I can see the corner from my second story window. Meridian Planning & Zt~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 57 Often times at night I like to leave the windows open, let it breeze in. We have some noise right now just from the traffic going on Franklin which isn't too bad. I don't frequently getting woken up by just regular traffic noise. To have increased traffic at 2 o'clock in the morning I don't know what the decibel levels will be increased by having more traffic there at that hour. The sound will carry better at night and I am concemed about the noise coming from the parking lot at 2 o'clock in the morning or after 10 or 11. I am also concerned about the precedent this property might set for businesses that might locate on the other comers or businesses that might shy away from locating on the other comers. I used to live by a bar myself too, so I can echo some of the comments that were made earlier and observations. No one mentioned what happened at my house, I had individuals trying to get into my house at all hours of the morning. I had to resort to calling the police. They responded they wouldn't be able to do anything that that time they wouldn't be able to do anything unless the person came in my house. I don't want to face that possibility again. The proposed owners say they keep control of things in their bar. Control is one thing but they can't give me a guarantee that they can control all of these individuals. Or control over individuals that may pull into their bar that may be DUI already. They may tum those customers away because of their condition then what is going to happen when those people leave. These people that may be frequenting some other bar and decide to change bars and decide to come to this bar at some hour of the night and get turned away. Well that is still increasing the liability of some kind of an accident or some unfortunate happening in my neighborhood. I don't want to have to deal with concerns of that or concerns of the children and so forth that has been voiced already. It seems to me it is (inaudible) in here tonight and primarily homeowners in the immediate vicinity of the bar. It seems to me the majority are definitely opposed. I would also like you to consider what is going to be, who will benefit the most from the decisions going forward from here. In other words what is the best for the most people involved. I recently received a flyer in the mail from the organization MADD, 1 don't know if it went city wide or county wide. But it mentioned an incident that happened in Maryland at about 8:40 in the morning, recognizing this is .before the bar hours. A mother was waiting at the end of her driveway with her nine year old daughter for the school bus. The school bus was approaching the daughter started approaching the bus. A car came whipping down their residential street at 50 miles per hour killing the girl. I don't want to have to be concerned with that at any hour of the day or night in my own neighborhood. Again I have lived dose to a bar before I know what the noise levels can be. People go in and go out those doors open, noise levels they are going to come booming out the door if it is loud in there. The sound will cany. I think that is about all I have. Thank you Johnson: Thank you Bruce Dayvell, 1187 W. Kimra, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Dayvell: I live just straight down SW 12"' Avenu3 in the Fenway Park Subdivision. Many times I have told people that as they drive down SW 12th that if they keep going down SW 12th they will drive right into my front lawn. I really don't want that to come true. I Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 58 think there are plenty of areas in this county or in this valley where bars can be built where they do not affect residential areas. I would ask these men if they would please consider one of. those areas instead of this. I realize that there my be a further drive but the people who will be frequenting this bar probably 99% of it will not be from the neighbofiood that they are going to be living next to. So they will not be able to say that these people will be able to walk over to this bar and visit this bar. Because the people who live there won't necessarily be frequenting it. Roy Carlson, 1340 S. Heidi, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Carlson: Gentlemen I know there has been a lot of testimony against the bar. I support the testimony against the bar as well. And echo all of the things that were said against it. I truly believe the Martell's do a very clean have a very clean business. I haven't heard of a lot of problems in their area. I am sure their clientele have been good but you cannot control what happens when people leave the door. Those are the kind of ramifications that we need to look What I would like to do is point out history. If you remember many years ago Garden City used to be the sleeping community if you paraphrase of Boise. Along that road there were many bars and it took a long time to clean up that area. There are still reminisces of the main road along Garden City that we are still dealing with a crime rate and those kinds of ramifications in the long term. Franklin Road right along here is spouting many bars within a very short period of time. Gentlemen as you are and should be visionary men consider this, consider a vision where Franklin Road could turn into a dichotomy of a Garden City. Do not let this happen. I agree with everything that was said against it. 1 would support the Martells to move anywhere else. I think there are too many bars on Franklin Road and I don't think we ought to allow any more to come into the area. Thank you Tyler Parrish, 871 W. Loon, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Parrish: I don't want a bar close to our neighborhood. I ride the bus to school and I don't want any drunk drivers driving through our neighborhood and by our house. I don't want drunk people in our neighborhood driving around. That is all. Brad Dalling, 1388 W. Crestwood, Meridian, was sworn by the City ,4ttorney. Dalling: I was just going to say like I don't really want the bar there because I would rather have a place like a gas station or something. Like my mom said like a park or something. I know that they sell beer and alcohol stuff at gas stations but I would rather see a gas station that sells stuff like that than a bar. That is all 1 have to say. Brent Myers, 323 S. Pennwood Place, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attomey. Myers: tt has been a long night. 1 just wanted to echo all of those who are opposed to building the bar on that comer. I drive down Franklin on my way to work and coming home especially from work I have to drive by a lot of those bars and I don't like it. It Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 59 gets really crowded and that is just at 5:00. I can see how that traffic problem is going to get worse. I know that the road is going to be widened and there is going to be a traffic light on that corner. But that is not going to help, It is really not going to help anything. I am very much opposed to that bar, I think there are other places in the City that they can build that without having quite that much impact. Steve Carlson, 1340 S. Heidi Place, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attomey. Carlson: I really don't want a bar there because like me and my friends we ride our bikes down that road to get to the Meridian Middle. If we had a bar there, there would be people outside drank and crap. I don't want like people getting drunk and then going around your neighborhood speeding. It is not that good. You could have a gas station and buy the same stuff and go somewhere else. That is all I have to say. Tyler Holdaway, 1150 W. Greenhead Street, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Hofdaway: 1 don't want the sports bar because there are little kids that go around with their parents that like push their kids around in carts and stuff. I even take my sister around in the neighborhood and she is only 1 '~. Also sports bar, even though they have sports why can't you just watch it at your house. Just go and buy beer somewhere and then invite your friends over and go to your house. You don't have to go to a bar to have a fun, you can have fun at your house and watch sports. t just don't want my sister to grow up and drink beer and all of that stuff. I don't think it is really good for you. We have teamed in school that it is not right. That is all I have to say. Johnson: Comments from the Commission, comments from Staff? Well at this point seeing no one to testify 1 will close the public hearing. Mr. Martell did you want to add anything or were you through? I will re-open this hearing so I will do that. Martell: I appreciate all of these people's concerns, most of them that are concerned aren't within the area that does concern. But I do appreciate their concerns if they don't want something in that particular area they have a right to speak up and say whatever they have to say about it. I don't plan on hurting the community, all t wanted to do was move to a nicer location and a new place. It is up to you guys, you make the decision. Borup: There were questions raised on seating capacity, do you know what the planned seating capacity is on your proposed building? Martell: Proposed right now it looks like about 120 I would estimate. Borup: What are you in your present building? Martell: We are about 75 to 80. Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 60 Borup: About how many do you know how many people presently you have on a typical night. Martell: 4n a typical night probably 40, on weekends we will pack the place at about 75. Borup: Would you anticipate, I kind of implied from some of your comments earlier there that one of your desires of the location there is because of the new, the five lane road anticipating probably increased exposure (inaudible) new patrons. Martell: New patrons, increased exposure. Where I am now I have really no exposure, most people have lived here all their life and still don't know where I am located at. Most of my clients it just comes from word of mouth. Smith: Excuse me Mr. Martell, are you planning on serving food? Martell: Yes we are, we are not going to have a kitchen but we will have quick foods which we do now such as pizzas and so forth. Johnson: The public hearing is still open is there anyone else before 1 close the public hearing? Christine Kellersbeger, 1219 Notel Creek, Meridian, was sworn by the City Attorney. Kellersberger: I do not live in Mallard Landing, I live in Parkside Creek. I was, I had a petition going around that said no to the sports bar. I went around just Big Creek and Blue Creek around there. I had an overwhelming response just even in my area which is by that new Albertson's out there. That even those people out there in that area do not want a sports bar because they are concerned for their children going to Meridian and coming home. Just as has been said before, just your teenage children. Teenage children have a tendency to crash cars. It is like 60% that collisions are under 21 and it is 50% that fatalities are by drunk drivers. I really am concerned about my owns children's safety coming home from games. They do go on that corner to go down to JB's or wherever that I do not want teenage drivers and drunk drivers mixing. That corner is very bad. So 1 just wanted to let people know that it is not just Mallard Landing it is other parts too of the City. Thank you Johnson: Thanks, okay at this poin# then I will close the public hearing. What would you like to do gentlemen? MacCoy: Mr. Chairman, I move that we have the attorney prepare facts and conclusions of law for this project. Smith: Second Meridian Planning & Z~g Commission September 9, 1997 Page 61 Johnson: We have a motion by Commissioner MacCoy and a second by Commissioner Smith to have the City Attorney prepare findings of fact and conclusions of law, all those in favor? Opposed? MOTION CARRIED: All Yea Johnson: We will have those prepared and will address those at our next meeting which is October 14~'. Any further discussion? We do have a new member tonight which is Mark Nelson and he sat here quietly this evening and observing but he is a member of our board and next meeting he is going to participate. He is going to participate right now by making our final motion of the evening. Nelson: I motion to adjourn. Smith: Second Johnson: l have a motion and a second to adjourn, all those in favor? Opposed? MOTION CARRIED: All Yea MEETING ADJOURNED AT 10:59 P.M. (TAPE ON FILE OF THESE PROCEEDINGS) APPROVED: ~~ JIM OHN HAIRMAN ATTEST: LLIAM G. BERG, JR., ,, a~~ LERK = S'I. .; ,~~~~~fil:iEt1S1~~~~` MERIDIAN PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION MEETING: Seatember 9.1997 APPLICANT: WILLIAM AND LYNN MARTELL AGENDA ITEM NUMBER: 15 REQUEST: PUBLIC HEARING REQUEST FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR A BEER WINE AND _~IQUOR SPORTS BAR AGENCY COMMENTS CITY CLERK: CITY ENGINEER: SEE ATTACHED COMMENTS CITY PLANNING DIRECTOR: SEE ATTACHED COMMENTS CITY ATTORNEY: CITY POLICE DEPT: "REVIEWED" CITY FIRE DEPT: SEE ATTACHED COMMENTS CITY BUILDING DEPT: MERIDIAN SCHOOL DISTRICT: MERIDIAN POST OFFICE: ADA COUNTY HIGHWAY DISTRICT: SEE ATTACHED COMMENTS ADA COUNTY STREET NAME COMMITTEE: CENTRAL DISTRICT HEALTH: SEE ATTACHED COMMENTS NAMPA MERIDIAN IRRIGATION: SEE ATTACHED COMMENTS SETTLERS IRRIGATION: IDAHO POWER: US WEST: INTERMOUNTAIN GAS: BUREAU OF RECLAMATION: OTHER: All Materials presented at public meetings shall become property of the City of Meridian. OFFICIALS WILLIAM G. BERG, JR., City Clerk JANICE L. SMITH, City Treasurer GARY D. SMITH, P.E., City Engineer BRUCE D. STUART, Water Works Supt. JOHN T. SHAWCROFT, Waste Water Supt. DENNIS J. SUMMERS, Parks Supt. SHARI L. STILES, P & Z Administrator PATTY A. WOLFKIEL, DMV Supervisor KENNETH W. BOWERS, Fire Chief W.L. "BILL" GORDON, Police Chief WAYNE G. CROOKSTON, JR., Attorney • HUB OF TREASURE VALLEY A Good Place to Live CITY OF MERIDIAN 33 EAST IDAHO MERIDIAN, IDAHO 83642 Phone (208) 888-4433 • FAX (208) 887-4813 Public WorksBuilding Department (208) 887-2211 Motor Vehicle/Drivers License (208) 888-4443 ROBERT D. CORRIE Mayor TO: Planning & Zoning Commission, Mayor & Council FROM: Bruce Freckleton, Assistant to City En ineer Shari Stiles, P&Z Administrator DATE: September 4, 1997 COUNCIL MEMBERS WALT W. MORROW, President RONALD R. TOLSMA CHARLES M. ROUNTREE GLENN R. BENTLEY P & Z COMMISSION JIM JOHNSON, Chairman MALCOLM MACCOY KEITH BORUP RON MANNING BYRON SMITH SUBJECT: Request for Conditional Use Permit for a Beer, Wine and Liquor Sports Baz by William and Lynn Martell Section 11-2-418.C of the Meridian Zoning and Development Ordinance states: The Commission and Council shall review the particular facts and circumstances of each proposed conditional use in terms of the following, and shall find adequate evidence showing that such use at the proposed location: a. Will, in fact, constitute a conditional use as determined by City policy; b. ill be harmonious with and in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan and this Ordinance; c. ill be designed, constructed, operated and maintained to be harmonious and appropriate in appearance with the existing or intended character of the general vicinity and that such use will not change the essential character of the same area; d. Will not be hazardous or disturbing to existing or future neighboring uses; e. till be served adequately by essential public facilities and services such as highways, streets, police and fire protection, drainage structures, refuse disposal, water, sewer or that the person responsible for the establishment of proposed conditional use shall be able to provide adequately any such services; C:~My Documerrtslrnartell.cup.doc • • Planning & Zoning Commission/1Vlayor & Council September 4, 1997 Page 2 f. ill not create excessive additional requirements at public cost for public facilities and services and will not be detrimental to the economic welfare of the community; g. ill not involve uses, activities, processes, materials, equipment and conditions of operation that will be detrimental to any persons, property or the general welfare by reason of excessive production of tra,,~'ic, noise, smoke, fumes, glare or odors; h. old have vehicular approaches to the property which shall be so designed as not to create an interference with tra,,~`ic on surrounding public streets; and i. Will not result in the destruction, loss or damage of a natural or scenic feature of major importance. The construction of a bar in the immediate vicinity of developed subdivisions, removed from the downtown core, would not appear to be a compatible land use and would undoubtedly put an additional drain on emergency services. As this property is located in a commercial zone, no second public hearing will be held. The application will go directly to City Council with the Commission's recommendation. We have preliminarily reviewed the above-referenced submittal and request that the following conditions, if the application is approved, be placed on the project. These conditions are to be complied with in full, unless expressly modified or deleted by motion of the Meridian City Council: 1. The project site is located on a portion of an existing parcel in a C-C zone. The minimum lot size in the C-C zone, according to the Zoning and Development Ordinance, is 8-30 acres. The property is being marketed as three separate pieces even though no legal split has taken place. Repeated requests for the Applicant's representative to include the entire parcel on their site plan have been ignored. Platting of the parcel into legal lots, and perhaps a rezone, is required prior to submitting any application for building permit that does not include development of the entire parcel. 2. ACHD policy will allow only one access to Franklin Road and one access to Ling Road for the entire parcel. A crossing of the Eight Mile Lateral will need to be constructed to allow vehicular cross access to the north. Applicant is to dedicate a total of 48 feet of • • Planning & Zoning Commission/Mayor & Council September 4, 1997 Page 3 right-of--way from centerline of Franklin Road. Revise site plan to conform to ACHD requirements and show centerline of roadway and property lines. Furnish copy of recorded warranty deed to the City Clerk's office for dedication of additional right of-way prior to submitting an application for building permit. 3. City Ordinance Section 11-9-605.G. requires that 20-foot-wide planting strips be placed next to incompatible features such as highways, railroads, commercial or industrial uses to screen the view from residential properties. Properties north and southeast are residential. A revised plan detailing a planting strip with a width as approved by the P&Z Commission is needed prior to action on this proposal. Detailed landscaping plans, including species and sizes of all plants, will be required prior to submitting an application for building permit. 4. A minimum of one (1) three-inch (3 ") caliper tree per 1,500 square feet of asphalt is required per City Ordinance Section 11-2-414.D. Provide calculations of asphalt areas and locate appropriate trees on site plan. 5. Provide fire access and hydrant locations in accordance with the Uniform Fire Code and Meridian Fire Department policies. 6. A screened trash enclosure is to be provided per City Ordinance. Provide details and location on revised site plan. Coordinate dumpster site locations with the City's solid waste contractor, Sanitary Services, Inc. Locate dumpsters so as not to impede fire access. 7. As Franklin Road is identified as an entrance corridor in the Meridian Comprehensive Plan, athirty-five-foot (35') landscape setback beyond required right-of-way is encouraged. Applicant is to provide detailed landscape plan, including terming details, for approval prior to obtaining building permits. Parking is not to encroach within the required landscape setback. 8. Applicant to provide curbing and underground sprinkler system for all landscaped areas. 9. Provide temporary fencing to contain debris during construction. • • Planning & Zoning Commission/Mayor & Council September 4, 1997 Page 4 10. All driveway and parking areas shall be paved, with all driveway accesses approved by the Ada County Highway District. Paving, striping and signage of parking lot to be in accordance with Meridian City Ordinance and the Americans with Disabilities Act. Driveway widths and parking stall lengths do not meet the requirements of City Ordinance Section 11-2-414; i.e., 2S-foot-wide driveway aisles with 9'x19' stalls. Graveled driveways, parking, and access will not be allowed. 11. A drainage plan designed by a State of Idaho licensed architect or engineer is required and shall be submitted to the City Engineer with calculations (Ord. 557, 10-1-91) for all off- street parking areas. All site drainage shall be contained and disposed of on-site. 12. Applicant is to obtain a certificate of occupancy prior to opening for business. 13. All signage shall be in accordance with the standards set forth in Section 11-2-415 of the City of Meridian Zoning and Development Ordinance, the Uniform Sign Code, and shall receive design approval of the Planning & Zoning Department. A-frame and other temporary signs and banners will not be permitted and will be removed upon 3 days notice to the Applicant. Sign permits are needed for all signage. 14. All building construction shall be in compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and all required Uniform Codes. 15. Applicant shall supply the Public Works Department with anticipated sewer and water usage for analysis in determining assessment fee to be charged. Assessment fees will be determined during the plan review process. A re-assessment agreement will be entered into with the Applicant prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy. 16. Provide parking lot lighting plans to the Meridian Public Works Department. Illumination of the site shall be designed to not cause glare or adversely impact neighboring residential properties, as determined by the City of Meridian. 17. The City of Meridian owns and maintains a sanitary sewer main in Franklin Road. Applicant will be responsible for extension of services into the subject property. The treatment capacity of the Meridian Wastewater Treatment Plant is currently being c:wnr ax~TSU..cur.noc • • Planning & Zoning Commission/Mayor & Council September 4, 1997 Page 5 evaluated. Approval of this application needs to be contingent upon our ability to accept the additional sanitary sewage generated by this project. 18. At this time, the City of Meridian does not have a water main in Franklin Road. However, plans have been developed to extend a 12-inch main in conjunction with the Franklin Road rebuild project. Service lines to the site shall be reviewed during the plan review process. 19. Water service to this project is contingent upon positive results from a hydraulic analysis by our computer model. 20. Any existing irrigation/drainage ditches crossing or adjacent to the property shall be tiled per City Ordinance 11-9-605.M. Plans will need to be approved by the appropriate irrigation/drainage district, or lateral users association, with written confirmation of said approval submitted to the Public Works Department. No variances have been requested for tiling of any ditches crossing this project. 21. Any existing domestic wells and/or septic systems within this project will have to be removed from their domestic service per City Ordinance Section 5-7-517. Wells may be used for non-domestic purposes such as landscape imgation. 22. All uses buildings shall be reviewed under the conditional use permit process. No details for the remainder of this parcel have been submitted. 23. The conditional use, if approved, shall be subject to review upon notice to the applicant. OFFICIALS G. BERG, JR., City Clerk L. SMITH, City Treasurer SMITH, P.E., City Engineer . ~JCE D. STUART, Water Works Supt. JOHN T. SHAWCROFT, Waste Water Supt. DENNIS J. SUMMERS, Parks Supt. SHARI L. STILES, P & Z Administrator PATTY A. WOLFKIEL, DMV Supervisor KENNETH W. BOWERS, Fire Chief W.L. "BILL" GORDON, Police Chief WAYNE G. CROOKSTON, JR., Attorney HUB OF TREASURE VALLEY • A Good Place to Live CITY OF MERIDIAN 33 EAST IDAHO MERIDIAN, IDAHO 83642 Phone (208) 888-4433 • FAX (208) 887-4813 Public WorksBuilding Department (208) 887-2211 Motor Vehicle/Drivers License (208) 888-4443 ROBERT D. CORRIE Mayor COUNCIL MEMBERS WALT W. MORROW, President RONALD R. TOLSMA CHARLES M. ROUNTREE GLENN R. BENTLEY P & Z COMMISSION JIM JOHNSON, Chairman MALCOLM MACCOY KEITH BORUP RON MANNING BYRON SMITH TRANSMITTAL TO AGENCIES FOR COMMENTS ON DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS WITH THE CITY OF MERIDIAN To insure that your comments and recommendations will be considered by the Meridian Planning & Zoning Commission, please submit your comments and recommendation to Meridian City Hall, Attn: Will Berg, City Clerk by: September Z, 1997 TRANSMITTAL DATE: 8/20/97 HEARING DATE: 9/9/97 REQUEST: Conditional Use Permit for a beer, wine and liquor ports bar BY: William & Lvnn Martell LOCATION OF PROPERTY OR PROJECT: Corner of Franklin and Linder Roads JIM JOHNSON, P/Z MALCOLM MACCOY, P/Z RON MANNING, P/Z BYRON SMITH, P/Z KEITH BORUP, P/Z BOB CORRIE, MAYOR RONALD TOLSMA, C/C CHARLIE ROUNTREE, C/C WALT MORROW, C/C GLENN BENTLEY, C/C WATER DEPARTMENT SEWER DEPARTMENT BUILDING DEPARTMENT FIItE DEPARTMENT _~POLICE DEPARTMENT CITY ATTORNEY CITY ENGINEER CITY PL MERIDIAN SCHOOL DISTRICT MERIDIAN POST OFFICE (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) ADA COUNTY HIGHWAY DISTRICT ADA PLANNING ASSOCIATION CENTRAL DISTRICT HEALTH NAMPA MERIDIAN IRRIGATION DISTRICT SETTLERS IRRIGATION DISTRICT IDAHO POWER CO. (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) U.S. WEST (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) INTERMOUNTAIN GAS (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) BUREAU OF RECLAMATION (PRELIM. & FINAL PL T) OTHER~ES ~_~~~ ~~ /~ /~ YOUR CONCISE REMARKS: Aug 2 s #s91 t~'Y Of l~~tAN ANNER - - +~ HUB OF TREASURE VALLEY • WILLIAM G. BERG, JR., City Clerk JAJJICE L. SMITH, City Treasurer GARY D. SMITH, P.E., City Engineer BRUCE D. STUART, Water Works Supt. JOHN T. SHAWCROFT, Waste Water Supt. DENNIS J. SUMMERS, Parks Supt. SHARI L. STILES, P & Z Administrator PATTY A. WOLFKIEL, DMV Supervisor KENNETH W. BOWERS, Fire Chief W.L. "BILL" GORDON, Police Chief WAYNE G. CROOKSTON, JR., Attorney A Good Place to Live CITY OF MERIDIAN 33 EAST IDAHO MERIDIAN, IDAHO 83642 Phone (208) 888-4433 • FAX (208) 887-4813 Public WorksBuilding Department (208) 887-2211 Motor Vehicle/Drivers License (208) 888-4443 ROBERT D. CORRIE Mayor COUNCIL MEMBERS WALT W. MORROW, President RONALD R. TOLSMA CHARLES M. ROUNTREE GLENN R. BENTLEY P & Z COMMISSION JIM JOHNSON, Chairman MALCOLM MACCOY KEITH BORUP RON MANNING BYRON SMITH TRANSMITTAL TO AGENCIES FOR COMMENTS ON DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS WITH THE CITY OF MERIDIAN To insure that your comments and recommendations will be considered by the Meridian Planning & Zoning Commission, please submit your comments and recommendation to Meridian City Hall, Attn: Will Berg, City Clerk by: September 2. 1997 TRANSMITTAL DATE: 8/20/97 HEARING DATE: 9/9/97 REQUEST: _Conditional Use Permit for a beer. wine and liquor snorts bar BY: William & Lvnn Martell LOCATION OF PROPERTY OR PROJECT: Corner of Franklin and Linder Roads JIM JOHNSON, P/Z MALCOLM MACCOY, P/Z RON MANNING, P/Z BYRON SMITH, P/Z KEITH BORUP, P/Z BOB CORRIE, MAYOR RONALD TOLSMA, C/C CHARLIE ROUNTREE, C/C WALT MORROW, C/C GLENN BENTLEY, C/C WATER DEPARTMENT SEWER DEPARTMENT BUILDING DEPARTMENT FIRE DEPARTMENT POLICE DEPARTMENT CITY ATTORNEY CITY ENGINEER CITY PLANNER MERIDIAN SCHOOL DISTRICT MERIDIAN POST OFFICE (PRELIM. & FINA~~~VE~ ADA COUNTY HIGHWAY DISTRICT ADA PLANNING ASSOCIATION AUIi 2 5 'I9~~ CENTRAL DISTRICT HEALTH NAMPA MERIDIAN IRRIGATION DISTRI~'ITY O~ MERIDIAN SETTLERS IRRIGATION DISTRICT IDAHO POWER CO. (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) U.S. WEST (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) INTERMOUNTAIN GAS (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) BUREAU OF RECLAMATION (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) CITY FILES ~*t OTHER: Zj YOUR CONCISE REMARKS: ~ ~ ~1~~ c7 /~ ~ // /may' • ~i /~ ,G /~ti r(/~' ~./ is ~~~~"~ -j'--, ' - Q ~ ~ ~ 1 ~. " 1S ~=L , ~ I i r- - oae~ ~~MO~ ~ r ~~~~ ~ ~f ' ~ ~ 4'~ 8 II ~_ , .. ~ _ . - -•---~+ ~ ~~~ -~ :; . ~~~ ~, ~~~ / ^,~'~ ( ^ ~~ v li :' Iv ~~ i _" . ~ i ~ ~ ~ e ~ r~ Q ~, .~.~ ; ~ ~ ~~ ~z ~: o~ ,. ~~ .~~ ~' .~ ' ~ .~ i ? ,~ ~ , ~r . } •` - I ~ l`i I'i f ~, .: ~ I ~t E ~ ~ ~:E ~ ~ ~~' f '~~ .., ' , .`,~~~ ~~~ ~~~~. ~'~ ~ ~I o ~~ ;, ((~ .I ~~ _~ ~~ ~ i ~ `~ t ~i .~ -~ ~~ ~ ~' ~: eti V ~ ~ M . • : i ~ ~ I ~ . »I ~~ ~ I ~ T r m ~ ~~ ~ ~ j ~ ` Q f ~.: J '' '~,h _ ~ d ~. ~, 1 N b Off'/ 7 o .,~ OL ~~ ~ _ i ~ ~ i i ~ ~ S i I i I /~/ I ~ ; I • ' ~ I CENTRAL C •• DISTRICT ~1'HEALTH DEPARTMENT Rezone # DISTRICT HEALTH DEPART'F1ENT Environmental Health Division Conditional Use # ~~~ l~/~C ~-' ~ ~ /QvO~L sso~n~ f~~~ Preliminary /Final /Short Plat Return to: ^ Boise ^ Eagle ^ Garden City Meridian ^ Kuna ^ Acz ^ I . We have No Objections to this Proposal. ^ 2. We recommend Denial of this Proposal. AUG 2 7 1997 ~I`fY©F MERIDIAN ^ 3. Specific knowledge as to the exact type of use must be provided before we can comment on this Proposal. ^ 4. We will require more data concerning soil conditions on this Proposal before we can comment. ^ 5. Before we can comment concerning individual sewage disposal, we will require more data concerning the depth of: ^ high seasonal ground water ^ waste flow characteristics ^ or bedrock from original grade ^ other ^ 6. This office will require a study to assess the impact of nutrients and pathogens to receiving ground waters and/or surface waters. ^ 7. This project shall be reviewed by the Idaho Department of Water Resources concerning well construction and water availability. 8. After written approval from appropriate entities are submitted, we can approve this proposal for: .~. central sewage ^ community sewage system ^ community water well ^ interim sewage central water ^ individual sewage ^ individual water ^ 9. The following plan(s) must be submitted to and approved by the Idaho Department of Health & Welfare, Division of Environmental Quality: ^ central sewage ^ community sewage system ^ community water ^ sewage dry lines ^ central water 10. Run-off is not to create a mosquito breeding problem. ^ I I. ^ 12. 13. ~. 14. This Department would recommend deferral until high seasonal ground water can be determined if other considerations indicate approval. If restroom facilities are to be installed, then a sewage system MUST be installed to meet Idaho State Sewage Regulations. We will require plans be submitted for a plan review for any: ^ food establishment ^ swimming pools or spas ^ child care center ~ beverage establishment ^ grocery store /~~ STDdZ~-1 w~,rz ~Q ~~ --o f-`~ ~S~i o v ~G~ ~D i.J Date: ~ l2~ l-L ~i o q~^a~5'S y ~ w~-L~.S ~ ~pr~~ 7-0 ~~c Si//,},Sv~2~y~C~ ~- C Reviewed By: /4.sti Review Sheet [DHD 10/91 rcb, rev. 1/97 S EP 0 2 1997 ~I'TY(}F ~ERORfAf~ & ~ ~. 1503 FIRST STREET SOUTH NAMPA, IDAHO 83651-4395 FAX # 208-888-6201 Phones: Area Code 208 Will Berg, City Clerk City of Meridian 33 East Idaho Meridian, ID 83642 RE: Conditional Use Permit for Sports Bar -William & Lynn Martell Dear Commissioners: OFFICE: Nampa 466-7861 Boise 343-1884 SHOP: Nampa 466-0663 Boise 345-2431 The Nampa & Meridian Irrigation District's Eightmile Lateral courses through the middle of the project. The right-of--way of the Eightmile Lateral is 60 feet; 30 feet from the center each way. See Idaho Code 42-1208--RIGHTS-OF-WAYNOT SUBJECT TO ADVERSE POSSESSION. The developer must contact John P. Anderson or Bill Henson at either 466-0663 or 345-2431 for approval before any encroachment or change of right-of--way occurs. The Nampa & Meridian Irrigation District requires a Land Use Change/Site Development application be Paled for review prior to final platting. All laterals and waste ways must be protected. All municipal surface drainage must be retained on site. If any surface drainage leaves the site, the Nampa & Meridian Irrigation District must review drainage plans. Contact Donna Moore at 343-1884 or 466-7861 for further information. The developer must comply with Idaho Code 31-3805. It is recommended that irrigation water be made available to all developments within the Nampa & Meridian Irrigation District. Sincerely, ~-- tll enson, Asst. Water Superintendent NAMPA & MERIDIAN IRRIGATION DISTRICT BH: dln cc: File -Shop File - O„~tce Water Superintendent APPROXIMATE IRRIGABLE ACRES RIVER FLOW RIGHTS - 23,000 BOISE PROJECT RIGHTS - 40,000 27 August 1997 • ~~n~~ SUSAN S. EASTLAKE, President GARY E. RICHARDSON, Vice President SHERRY R. HUGER, Secretary September 2, 1997 William and Lynn Martell 2241 NW 10th Street Meridian, Idaho 83642 Re: Staff Level Approval MCU-30-97 Franklin Road e/o Linder Road Sports bar Facts and Findings: ~' A. The Ada County Highway District (ACRD) staff has received the above referenced application requesting conditional use approval to construct a 3,240-square foot sports bar. The 0.66-acre site is located on the north side of Franklin Road approximatel~~ 175-feet®east of Linder Road. This development is estimated to generate 250 additional vehicle trips''per day based on the Institute of Transportation Engineers Trip Generation manual. B. The application and site plan received by the City of Meridian and submitted to the District on August 21, 1997, have been reviewed by tl~e ACRD Development Services staff and conforms to applicable District standards/policy, or can be made to conform with the change(s) to the plan described in the requirements stated below. This is a staff level approval and will not be heard by ACHD's Commission unless the site plan is changed°.in such a manner as to not conform with District standards/policy or an appeal of the Development Services staff decision is submitted as described within the Standard Requirements"outlined below. C. The District has completed the design for improving Franklin Road from E. 1st Street to Linder Road''to acquire the needed right-of--way for that project. The following requirements are provided as recommendations for conditions of approval to the City of Meridian: " Site Specific Requirements: Provide a $1,164.50 deposit to the Public Rights-of--Way Trust Fund at the District for the required street improvements of approximately 137-feet of 5-foot wide concrete sidewalk on ada county highway district 318 East 37th • Boise, Idaho 83714-6499 • Phone (208) 345-7680 • i Franklin Road abutting the parcel, prior to District approval of the final plat or issuance of a building permit (or other required permits), whichever occurs first. 2. Provide a recorded cross access easement for the parcels to the east and west to use this parcel for access to the public streets prior to issuance of a building permit (or other required permits). The District intends to require a similar agreement of the owners of the parcels to the east and west if they are the subject of a future development application. 3. Utility street cuts in new pavement less than five years old are not allowed unless approved in writing by the District. Contact Construction Services at 345-7667 (with file number) for details. 4. Coordinate the construct of a driveway on Franklin Road with District Plans and Surveys staff. 5. Provide a $2,700.00 Deposit to the Public Right-of--Way Trust Fund to construct a 6-inch raised median in the center of Franklin Road extending from the Franklin/Linder intersection to a point 270-feet east. The District will construethe median as part of the 1998 reconstruction project. 6. Graveled driveways abutting public streets create maintenance problems due to gravel being tracked onto the roadway. Pave the driveway its full required width of 30 to 36-foot wide to at least 30-feet beyond the edge of pavement of Franklin Road. 7. As required by District policy, restrictions on the width, number and locations of driveways, shall be placed on future development of this parcel 8. Other than the access point specifically approved with this application, direct lot or parcel access to Franklin Road is prohibited.. Standard Requirements: This decision of the Development Services Supervisor may be appealed to the Ada County Highway District Commission by the applicant or by an owner of property within 300-feet of the parcel within 15 calender days from the date of this report. The request shall specifically identify each requirement to be reconsidered and include a written explanation of why such a re uirement would result in a substantial hardship or inequitX The request will be heard by of the'appe, meeting..: Commission at an evening meeting within 20 calender days of the District's receipt `1 letter. The appellant will be notified of the date and time of the Commission MCU3097.SLA Page 2 • 2. After ACRD Commission action, any request for reconsideration of the Commission's action shall be made in writing to the Development Services Supervisor within two days of the action and shall include a minimum fee of $110.00. T-he request for reconsideration shall specifically identify each requirement to be reco . idered and 'nclude written documentation of da a that ~!as not available to t_he Commission at he tim of it' original decision The request for reconsideration will be heard by the District Commission at the next regular meeting of the Commission. If the Commission agrees to reconsider the action, the applicant will be notified of the date and time of the Commission meeting at which the reconsideration will be heard. 3. Payment of applicable road impact fees are required prior to building construction in accordance with Ordinance #188, also known as Ada County Highway District Road Impact Fee Ordinance. 4. All design and construction shall be in accordance with the Ada County Highway District Policy Manual, ISPWC Standards and approved supplements, Construction Services procedures and all applicable ACHD Ordinances unless specifically waived herein. 5. The applicant shall submit revised plans for staff approval, prior to issuance of building permit (or other required permits), which incorporates zany required design changes: 6. Construction, use and property development shall be in conformance with all applicable requirements of the Ada County Highway District prior to District approval for occupancy. 7. Any change by the applicant in the planned use of the property which is the subject of this application, shall require the applicant to comply with all rules, regulations, ordinances, plans, or other regulatory and legal restrictions in force at the time the applicant or its successors in interest advises the Highway District of its intent to change the planned use of the subject property unless awaiver/variance of said requirements or other legal relief is granted pursuant to the law in effect at the time the change in useis sought. 8. No change in the terms and conditions of this approval shall be valid unless they are in writing and signed by the applicant or the applicant's authorized representative and an authorized representative of the Ada County Highway District. The burden shall be upon the applicant to obtain written coilyumation of any change from the Ada County Highway District. MCU3097.SLA Page 3 • Conclusion of Law: • 1. ACHD requirements are intended to assure that the proposed use/development will not place an undue burden on the existing vehicular and pedestrian transportation system within the vicinity impacted by the proposed development. Should you have any questions or comments, please contact the ACRD Development Services staff at 345-7662. Sincerely, Larry Sale Development Services Supervisor cc: Project file Lead agency MCU3097.SLA Page 4 • '~aosr~ia. & ~fe~udiact ~vugat~oct ?~cdacict 1503 FIRST STREET SOUTH NAMPA, IDAHO 83651-4395 FAX # 208-888-6201 2 9 August 19 9 7 Phones: Area Code 208 OFFICE: Nampa 466-7861 William & Lynn Martell Boise 343-1884 2 2 41 N . W . 10th SHOP: Nampa 466-0663 Meridian, ID 83642 Boise 345-2431 RE: Land Use Change Application for Sports Bar - Franklin & Linder Dear Mr. and Mrs. Martell: Enclosed please find a Land Use Change Application for your use to file with the Irrigation District for its review on the above- referenced development. If you have any questions concerning this matter please feel free to call on me at the District's office or John Anderson, the District's Water Superintendent at the District's shop. Sincerely, ~• ~~" ~. Donna N. Moore, Assistant Secretary/Treasurer dnm cc: File Water Superintendent G. Matthew Thomas City of Meridian enc. C~Op~ APPROXIMATE IRRIGABLE ACRES RIVER FLOW RIGHTS - 23,000 BOISE PROJECT RIGHTS - 40,000 HUB OF TREASURE VALLEY • WILLIAM G. BERG, JR., City Clerk JANICE L. SMITH, City Treasurer GARY D. SMITH, P.E., City Engineer BRUCE D. STUART, Water Works Supt. JOHN T. SHAWCROFT, Waste Water Supt. DENNIS J. SUMMERS, Parks Supt. SHARI L. STILES, P & Z Administrator PATTY A. WOLFKIEL, DMV Supervisor KENNETH W. BOWERS, Fire Chief W.L. "BILL" GORDON, Police Chief WAYNE G. CROOKSTON, JR., Attorney A Good Place to Live CITY OF MERIDIAN 33 EAST IDAHO MERIDIAN, IDAHO 83642 Phone (208) 888-4433 • FAX (208) 887-4813 Public WorksBuilding Department (208) 887-2211 Motor Vehicle/Drivers License (208) 888-4443 ROBERT D. CORRIE Mayor COUNCIL MEMBERS WALT W. MORROW, President RONALD R. TOLSMA CHARLES M.ROUNTREE GLENN R. BENTLEY P & Z COMMISSION JIM JOHNSON, Chairman MALCOLM MACCOY KEITH BORUP RON MANNING BYRON SMITH TRANSMITTAL TO AGENCIES FOR COMMENTS ON DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS WITH THE CITY OF MERIDIAN To insure that your comments and recommendations will be considered by the Meridian Planning & Zoning Commission, please submit your comments and recommendation to Meridian City Hall, Attn: Will Berg, City Clerk by: September 2. 1997 TRANSMITTAL DATE: 8/20/97 HEARING DATE: 9/9/97 REQUEST: Conditional Use Permit for a beer, wine and liquor snorts bar BY: William & Lvnn Martell LOCATION OF PROPERTY OR PROJECT: Corner of Franklin and Linder Roads JIM JOHNSON, P/Z MALCOLM MACCOY, P/Z RON MANNING, P/Z BYRON SMITH, P/Z KEITH BORUP, P/Z BOB CORRIE, MAYOR RONALD TOLSMA, C/C CHARLIE ROUNTREE, C/C WALT MORROW, C/C GLENN BENTLEY, C/C WATER DEPARTMENT SEWER DEPARTMENT BUILDING DEPARTMENT FIRE DEPARTMENT POLICE DEPARTMENT CITY ATTORNEY CITY ENGINEER CITY PLANNER MERIDIAN SCHOOL DISTRICT ~~E1VEp MERIDIAN POST OFFICE (PRELIM. & FIN AT) ADA COUNTY HIGHWAY DISTRICT gUti 2 5 1997 ADA PLANNING ASSOCIATION CENTRAL DISTRICT HEALTH ~~r p~ MERIDIAN NAMPA MERIDIAN IRRIGATION DISTRI SETTLERS IRRIGATION DISTRICT IDAHO POWER CO. (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) U.S. WEST (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) INTERMOUNTAIN GAS (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) BUREAU OF RECLAMATION (PRELIM. & FINAL PLAT) CITY FILES ~ • ~ ~iv~ Tim & Anita Burgess BBC 735 Hanover Court CEP _ 8 ~~~] Meridian, Idaho 83642 Home (208)888-6618 G~'TY OF I~ERII~IAIV Work (208)888-4312 September 5, 1997 City of Meridian Planning and Zoning Commission 33 East Idaho Street Meridian, ID 83642 Re: 'tal Use~ermit Application - n and Lyme MarteIl Gentlemen: I am opposed to the City of Meridian granting a conditional use permit to construct a "Sports Bar" on the northeast corner of Franklin Road and Meridian Road. I am requesting that the planning and zoning commission deny this application request. Due to a conflict, I am unable to attend the public hearing to be held on September 9, 1997. Please enter this letter into the official record as my testimony. Thank you for considering my input. Sincer y, ~% Tim Burgess mfr cE~~ E~ , ... I .. , ' ~ _ ... SEp ~0.9~ 19~J7 ~, .. :. - :ITS ~t nERi01a~` - C~~ ` ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ Qerv~ P~~ eK: U ~r ~ c°`~r~ 5 `?~ ~ ~° ~~ ~ . `. ~ . ~-~~L `I n ~p - W ' 1. ~t~ 1 ~ (~ S ~S ~C~J o~ ~ `'~~ Cc~~~ ~ ~ r5 ~O~- ~~ ~,~~ ~~s" ~ u' ~ ~ ~os~ Sa ~ ~5 _ ~ `~ ~~ __ . , ~G ~ ~~ rn~ ~ ~ ~ti~ ~ f .~:,~ ~ .~~~ - ~ sc ~,, ,~ :.:~ ` ; a~S t ~,~~. .- ~~. r ., ~ `;t t~. (mod// CIo-~~~ ~ b5 ~L In~UI~ more. ~f~ 5. Nes 5 rn~~.~, S13~`tz r~ t7 4 September 1997 1- ~~t Yl n ~ 1~1a~ c~ ZrH ~ w~ Cc~.n m ~ SS ~o~ Meridian City Council City of Meridian Idaho Street Meridian, Idaho 83642 Dear Council Members: ~ ~~ Cam. • R~c~~ SEP - 9 1997 C17Y Oc~~ It has been brought to our attention that there is a recliyest in process to build a "Sports Bar" on the Northeast corner of Franklin and Linder roads. This causes our family grave concern, and we ask that this action NDT he approved. We have outlined below some of the reasons why this is inappropriate: l . This location is extremely close to residential areas where there are many small children and families who would be in harm's way from the influences of a business that has no business being close to a residential area. 2. There are no aiteniate routes out of neighborhoods to the south of the proposed location. This corner is the only logical ingress and egress for vehicle traffic for approximately 30D homes in several subdivisions. Residents would have no choice to avoid passing by the bar. ~. Students walking south on Colder from Meridian High School must pass by the proposed location. From the railroad tracks south to Crestwood there are no sidewalks for foot traffic. Linder is very narrow for this '/a mile, and students and others are in some danger even with sober, alert drivers due to the heavy #lativ of traffic coming #ram the schboi. We shudder to think of the increased danger to pedestrian traffic if any of the drivers' reflexes were impaired by alcohol. 4. We purchased our home five years ago not realizing that a sportsbar may be built so close to our property. This will Have a dramatic effect on the property values for all of the Homes in the surrounding neighborhoods. Had we known of the possibility that a bar would be buih, we would not have naught in Mallard Landing. Dave environmental impact studies been done to determine the impact that a sportsbar will have on our neighborhoods? Have you looked at the potential risks to our neighborhood children, changes in crime rates, accident rates, number of citations issued, value of property, etc., that come about because of the addition of undesirable elements? Does Meridian want to develop the refutation that Garden City has worked so diiigentl-y tb change for the better? As you can see, we are extremely concenied about this proposal and heartily endorse not granting a permit for the construction of the sports bar. Thank you for your consideration on our behalf on this matter. Sincerely, ~ ~~ ~~ Fran Barnhart 1418 W. Merganser Dr. Meridian, ID $3542 Vince Earnhart 1418 W. Merganser Dr. Meridian, ID 83542 ~C~V~ SEP - 9 1997 • (~h~~ ~h~s ~-ss~ ~~~c~~ns~. CrtY OF ~[~RIDIAH • ~- ~ I I~ S ~. Apr ~' ~~, I I ~ r~ ~ n n' S ~ a u n~-e, j~1 A 11 ~. ~ i rn ~~ ~~ ~ ~ S'~ of ~S ~~ nG1 T I l~C. ~, r1 ~~ Y" ~ n~~ ~~'n~1',`rc~~n~~e~.~. ~~ ll ~ L`~~`n~ ~~.e own~.S, S~.p~ar~~ ''~r-~1 ~/c1r~ G~ndl ~ti.r~oU.n~ ih~ Cbn~/h~.n,+~~ ~~c~9 ~ ~~' vl -~ ~-`rr (J -~ ~atm )I I~~~~C.e `~~`~t~ I Cv ~,/~n~/~11, p~S ~'~r CG m m cs u~`~ ~-~ a~- h I~. ~~ ~--~Ct r~ ~ S r ba~~~ aalc.+, l ~ ~ ~~ ;~ Q l1C~ ~( ~ S , ~ ~ i'~1 ~ r1t ~ ~ D~ ~~ i n ~~ ~ 1~71`~Yc~Ch'IP.C :~ ~ ~ LAS ~~~ e I ci ~ ~ k n ~ ~-hc.~- ~~ ;r~~ ~~ Cctills -~=~r mfr-~~'~c~~ ~~L.I`-~~~ ~~,~~,1 d r G.r~ ~ S ~~ rG c~ ~ ~ n~tc~~c~ -~ h~ t~ ~ l ,e ~~ l ~ ; l ~ ~~e ~~. ~-- ~~~~ ~ti~s perms n s ~~~ \~~~ ~ ~. ~tnd hew ~ ~ ~S~u~~-t~i ~~ ~ ~~- c{ ~ ~ a ~ ~~ -F ~ ~ ~ h s ,, ~i ~ rw~~ ~~~:~L rvS c~ ~-~ ~ (l ~ L,~ ref,' S . ~ ~~~~' u~Fn`~l ~~ ~ ~, r ~~d ~ ti ~ c~,b ~ ~~r~ ~ r ~ ~~'~ s ~ a t~ n.~~ Qn~ h~~~e ~ ~~ ~. n~ ~ ~ :.l-. r~ ~- ~ C~'~r1.t}u ~ a2n b~~T~~i~n s ~1 bb ~c.~ i C ~ttr1 5 ~~ ~I~,c . G~-'icl ~C~r~~~-~~ ,~/yyYYtun~ ~~ i ~,~,I~s ~~ ~.; C7 C~~~ SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! SEP - 9 1997 '-= G~tY ~~ We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print LT....... f • ~.1____ aavu~. n Ul 141416 -' ~ ` i ' i ~_..._ t- ~,~ _.~a_ ~ , ~" ~ 5.1.. LV l~ ~~~ W (~~~ ~ V~~ /. ;~ it G~.-~~I ~J~f.~ "~1~ , / / .~! ~, . x L~ e "~- 7. ~~ €'e~.. /~~.o rl~ /~ , _ , y ~d.f ( ( I~ ~"~ f_"_~~~~ ~/ ~c r1~~L~ _ ~ -'1 '~-` ~'" ~~~1J 8. ~, ~ ~~ I,~• j ~ /1 J &, 1. Il'fi V,~ y ~~• f/I ` 4'l• / rl/ ~VI µ'~ 9. ~ h r ~~ ~'1K.1~ ~ ~ Zq W C 1-'PEq ~ P~ ~ r . ~ ~ d~~ 11. ~y~ lUl . ~''~~ 3~1~13 1 8- ~ 13.~ ~ ~, gt~ o~ 14. ~ ~ ~ .,~~~ ~~ L 7 1 ~~ J 10. ' / / _ 1 19~ e l 1,J reeh e,~ -~ 5 2 , Zo. 21. • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name Address PhnnP f! Civnafi~rn 1. ; ~~ 9a - 2. ' S`3 ~..~ _ [. ~ -~ `mot - ~{ - y ~ < 5. ~ ' ~ ~~ 6..~~~ ~ ~ 3 `' 8. 1 f `~ 1 l ~ ~ ~'1 ~ ~J v 1 ~' 10~,~ ~ Lw-~is ~~~ ~~. Grecr~hen~4 ~- ~4 S- b~3 3 11. '' ~~ G(vC~ W~ ~ - r/ .~ ,. 12. 'E 'l t?Z ~ ~ S`C ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~Zy a 13 ~3 C ~ ~ ~ `T I 15. ~ .~. ~ ~ ~ l - `,~ ~~ ~ ~- ~ ~~ ~. S 16. as ~~s s~~- ~~ z ~ w . U -~,~,,~~~ 17. 18. " ~ jD~ ~C n+ n ~~a ... Q .i -, 19 ~- ~ ~~ ~ - - Zo. ~ ~ ~, ~ ~ ~s 7- 18 `~ ~,~ 21. S~ r1~.~, G~3") 1~.J. Gfe-t-hhtad ~~ $g1-5~76 .~ ~~ J • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name Address PhnnP i! Cion~t»ra 1. ,~~ ~3 ~ ~ ~ ~.~~ 7 ,~,(// 2. ~~/,jEi ~ ~ ~ ~J ~~•~.~ f''~~ ~~~ O ~ ~ 3.~(Rrh/1i ~lli ~ CIC~ C:I~~~InC'ri~ It ~, ~r 5. c, C ~ , n '1 ~`~ ~' L ~. SCE ~' _ ~, 6~~~h 3 ~3~ S ~M~sc~.~~ Ike d~''~-~S9 7.` i1jSL ~er. ~f ~3 ~ ~IUSLG.+~ ~C 17 C% ~'J - ~d~ / l ~' ~ r~c~~x~ , 7// ~ a ~ ~ ~ l0. ~ ~3 Z~~ (ph7~ SiN~ ~ ~ ..~ Z $ C~ 11. ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~~~ 1 ~~t ~f ~ ~7 ~- f~ 13. ~~ ~ J / v~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~` l~ ~~T }~7 ~ ~ Z 1 ' ~ ~- V O lV `~'- e6C 5 16. ~ w o7S w . F1.~c~ ~ ~(_ ~ - S~ - ls. r ~ e ~S4 073 1 v ~ ~c ~" - D J 3 '~/ Zo. ~ 3 21. Er/ b~5 ~Q~~NKE~-I 5f~ -9 ~rcti,~~~~ 7 • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ddress hone # Si lure ~ue ~--I qqa W. Loin eri~l..iu 8~~1-33~~r 2. t- r ~ g71 ~ . L...pp ~e ' - Z Z 7 3. 4 ~Uy2. --CK1~ ir' ~e CZl R `~-~~1 Gt~~ l-- b o N m G l4 ( A t ri. N ~ ~ `~ ~ obi / ~7 ~o 5. I Q Vl ( ~l ~P P ~ ~ i ~ i~ ti `~ "~~~ 6 ~, s ~ ~~, d,~~ ~ `/- ~o sr ~ ~. ja/ ~- ~ ~ 5 `~ -~ ~ 1 9. ~ 1~1 7 ~~ ' ~ (~}.'~ to.~ ~~,~, 6s~ (.J • Z~o~ mo`d' ~~S -1`~5~ 11. S'~ F1~ ~~~ w, ~~~,v F ~ti g~Z( S~ 12. v ra d (~ ~ o o ~^ ~ D 13. ~ / ~ (~ ~0~7~ 0 ~7~ ~~o l~ ls. n~lt~ ~ DD ~ ~ / 19. ~~ 8' ~1 ~~ ~ 21 ~~.~/LI.A ~Frt '>~ 6~Z-- 1 nj , ~r'~~il~--" ~C~ ~ )S7_~ I nJ SAY NO TO SPORTS BARt . We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. ~ Please print _ __ _, . • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name `AAAre+ec Dt,n..e ~ C:...... ~_~~~ 1. ~~ . ~1 ~, Q ~ • ppi~pp 0 0 ~ ~~ •14L41 V \ 2.~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~v1.c~D ~~ ~ ~ ~7~ 3.5 ~ `ad g l,J . ~lWavD S - 4 3 4. I ~ O ~ ~ 7 _5~, 6~ ~~ W • ~' ~-~w~a S ~~ I ~l gl~ -- ~T ~ -~o~ to ~ f ~ ~ [ ~~ i~ ~~ t ~ --.: 1 "l 12.L~S L~fM4.~, /d5' ~' L/ ~'~NG.j~x~ ~ 7-9~0~ 1 (.f/i ~/ ~T ~ ^~ / . 15. ~ l ~0~~ ~- ~ 7! ' ~ ~. 17. a achs f D 4 tU ~ ~ 7 635 ' . 1 ~ l ~ (~ f~. ~ ,- f ~ S' zd~f~rtela ~ ~~~ I~ ~'en~~v~d~ ~~~- ~ 92 ~ ~~j ~~ ~` ~ ~ ~'~~ ~~ -- _ ~ • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR1 We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the corner east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print ,, _. _ ~... „z-- ~ ~.~------ -~ 1. . ~~r' ~ r ~~ s P~-.~- ~~1-.~~o i 2 Gt U ~ - f ~l i ~ '~ ~ ' .Prs1i1~.~L~ ~~ ~Q ~ - ~~6 ~ - . cs~' /V i CXJ rr3'' ' ~ ~c 7 ~ ~ ti~ ~ `~ g~ <~ 2 ~ ~ ~'~7 - d 82 / 10.i- V /~_ ~~ 11. ~ ~ •~ ~ ~ `~O • 12 ~e e : u ~t~ HS 5 GL~. s-~o C.c • ~ 0 ' !o s d 13. /Vt a ~S ~ 2 id ~v(ee ~- ~~ d~c~d'^ b s d•' 1 .' ~ ~~er ~) ~ ~~' ~~-~- '3 ._. 15..f~C` , ct 1 ~ e~ ~ ~~ \ ~ o ~~ ~ i e 1 d r _ ~ _ ~ I 1 I ~ ,~- 16. e z 17 -~~~~ ~~~ 6 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~8'' - ~o ~ 2 ~~ 1 ,yl~a~~~'' lam- 6 ~ ^ °-ot Cc } ~ ~ - 7 ~ ~~ ,c~P."Y 19 ~ '" Gs U 20, 1 ~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ,~ C`'/ ~~' ~ • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print c,- name aur~~ ,,.,.,~ ,. ,~.. 2 ~ ~ ~ bey D ~ ~'uvne 5 ' ~/3 S 3. !'~, , - ~~d . 4. t fie, f ~' /O ~ t5 ~~'r 7~~ 6. .~ ~ ~~ - GY7 7 Z., ~. ~ ~~cE ~~G-~ ~~- lay f~ • ~~ s-- - , 9. ~.~.- ~--, 9 3 s . ~t.~-~1~C. ~ ~ - ~J c1 oZ. 10 ~I~G ~ ~ 11. ren .~4 ~g8/ Gfi, sllil//1/1~ .~~O,l~ ,~/~ Z I ~A- ~ - 7 - 7~ Z ,~ B ~- C7yC.~j ~~~~ ll 13. ~Q 5 c;~ ~ ~ 00 1 ~_t6 ~,~_ 4 S. ~^ 8 15 ~' tv~1 ~' ' Q I ~ ~ ~ '1 16 / ~ 18. C C t ~U '1~1 en;N 'ood b3~f ~~~ r 19. ~ c- 1, l N~ \ C~~ 1 `~ `~ 20. _ ~' ~~7~ ~ _,. 21./~~[K i/ _ l ~~ `.~- ~Llf?4.~~ S7 - - ~s ~7' ~~~~I • SAY NO TO SPORTS BART We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Ptease print Name ddress hone # Si tore >.~aek-` L.g~r° 3(~0 ~, ot,c~i'~el d UJ 88'-7-og~l 2. omrn ~ ~j'i S 3(oD S', ©a.~~i~~~- ~ ~~ - 0~~1 4 1t2 ~ .~ 3 ~ Cc.~ .. (~, ~7- 0 X3.6 5. ~ ~ ~ 3s ~ ~~y~/~ . `l \ ate. ,~... n C_ ~..,, i _ ~ •~ µ i l ~ l l /A!/ Y ~, 2 ~. -a7a Su S~ ,~i~c~o ~/ ~s ~ ~-~ Ob ~~ ~~~ -~375~ ~~ ~ ~, owe ~r~I~ w~ ~~~ ~ ~/ / e ~~ 5; ~~ ~'~ 4.;~ ~'~~/ /98~ ~~ 3 plJ ~ ~ ~- l 5 ~. _ •-~ f ~.... ~,%1 ~~ ~ 7n i~~ ~~~ncLr~~.~„ ,9 SCg 7- ~v 5S $' .=i _, .. • ~~~ ~~ ~ ~M i .~ ,~ ~ ~~~ ~~ ~~ L S .~ a,~ ~~ ~~. ~" • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! ~~aW~ We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name 'AriArPCC Ahnnn ~f C; a., 1. i s~ ~' ~vh r. o ~ -$ $ 3~6 2. ~ !~ 1/ GJ ~ ~~- 3. i~ " ~ ~ x.17 • "3~ S 4. ~ / oui /d Z0 ~. G ~ g4 ~ ~ ~ 3 ~/ 6. I ~ 7 ~. ~ i aas~~ I ~~1 1nl' ~ v~'al ~- ~~1-~~~-- ~ ~ s. ~ 9. tex~5 ~ ,~, ~~ - ~9 ~~ 12. s ~ ~ a ~ l ~'~O ?_9 . 13. ~ a1 Qr - Zy~ 1 ~ °/` ~ Q ~ ~l / ~J 17. ,n , ` fly .Sp ~e~~eaa~ ~~ ~-~oc~ l ~' 19. ~ e $ ~ - Z 3 20 1 w W $~r - ~K2 r. 3 r ~ • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BARB We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 114 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ddn,ss hone # Si e 1. bfftS ~ Gs5 .Sup id` ~ Q0~ I Mer,'d,`Q 2. L, ~c ~7~ N• l'~uvenl Co~~ ~/-DO(o~ ~ _ 3. / -3 4. ~ O s. ~3P 3 ~ l~,c , g8-6 ~ ~' 8 6. ~ ~~ Un 9/-2 7~c Czl. ~ ~Ier-:~-~H g~7' ~ f8'ZO o ~. w ll~ d ` gg ~ 0 9. ~.~'-~~' F ~r I i too uJ n ~ ~ ~.s~ sp 3 ~ 3 ~ d `15f r lo.~.~ ~-~` , ``' "1$~ I v'i~~, R ~ ~ ~ I D ~ g X n - ~jo 3p 01 ~ r 11. e I r . - ~/ 5 12.E ' ' S1 ~ ~. ' ' .~S ' ~~y - , 14.~ 4r~ ~ ZO~oO ~ , ~ju,ti S -- Me., ~`87_'.p5 V~ I 15. a ~~... ~ ~ 2~cob W 5~~~ 5~o e ~B~ to S4 eSi ~^ LLw 16. ~cr ~ S /1/o rrls 2v ss" S .t/a ~ cr tai ~ $~ lvo 8 17. ~ vi « c~C IZo~ Ul, N~z ~~nt~~. ~ ~$• yId 18. Kc~ f~r~is~ 0248$ Gv. Luce ~ /~-r~~~d,~r gS~7r 3`r63 ao ~ ~K ~ 2 ~ oo w ~ r~~^ 18~~ 21. 'Z fTr7 tn~ ~ - ~ i • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name jAddrecc PhnnP !t Rionat„rn A / ~~~~ ~~7 ~ 3; ll~~i 1~i' ilo~ ,Zbl Iv. /Vu~ Cr- Jam(. ~~ ~ (oL U ' ~ ,,.~ 4. .-Ti,i ~ tJ I~(U I /J. ~otQ~ ~~ ^~ g~~-c~G~o ~-~o%li%~ `...,,_,~, L 2 '~~ ~~ - 9'' y / ~~ 7. I ~ ~ ~ y ~~r~ s. ~. ;~" ~~ 1 l ~ ~ ~ ~-P LZ? ~ ~L 88'7'3 9. ' u,rc~ ~ 1.:~'e >; ~'/ 8'7 8335. 11-C~r ~ er CXe 8 - 5~br 12. ~ ~'' y 105 W Qrr re ~~ ~~;~~ 14. ~ ~ 6'~. / ~ ~ r ~ , J 16. ` C.~t~r'~ ti Z ~~ ~J< caw ~/~ C~ ~ ~ ~ '7g~~ 1-C/- 17. ~N ~~„ ~ (~'(~ -.r (Z~ ~ ~ S~~ ~,e,e~ c„f gS~ - l z 33 ~,,,~ f4,,. w 1//,{ ~ e~,..C.QO 1s.I~C~ - t'1 1317 IU. r `~ r 7-'f?fir 19. ~ ~/~-t,F Lf~l~i E ~ ~-Sc~tc~ ~~ ~' c~i' ~8~- y 7 YJ 20. ~. ~ r ~ ~ ' ~~ "~y " ~ ~T..Z- (~~ ~ 21~+~~~) .~ ~i 4z3~1 ra. ~ Cve (_' Pk .. ~I~~~3. . :2~- • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ` ddress hone # Si lure Lar 1 i ~ ~/ ~'r~e ~~'~ '/33 ' :, 2. ~(. ~" ~~ (~ ~ ~ ~~ (~ ~ ~ ~Z~~ "L~l Z'~ r 1 ~ ~° °~ /~ ~ 4. a~~ ~ ' r~~~ ~ ~ ~ce-_- ~~ ~ egg-ssa ~. ~ ~ a 1, 7-11 ~ F'rL~~tQ-efC- Lvu~ ~'-~g~ol 1 -~' ~" .~ ~ ~- ~1 C.9 12. ~~ ~ 13. ~ t\l. ~~ ~~L 14. ~•(.u, o~ N. ~~~ S 15. ~~ \ 16. ~g'~ S'r~ S~~ C~-r- 88~s -S~6 ~ 17. ~~~~. G-~~OS ~~~ ~e~ 5~~~ C~ ~'~~ _q ~6 ~~~ 19. ?7)~ -~~~ Zo. 1~ i'1 ~~~~- ~r ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Shy ~ ~'---~ . _ 21. 3~a~ ~ ~ ~~ ~'~. C~: g 8~-- ~~~ ~- v ~ ~ • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ~AA~iresc PhnnP dt 6 ---- 1. 0 ~ ~ -- - b~ ~ N~Asf~cl~ ~ $$ 7 -1 q 7 ...~.a.~ 2, 'Gt 4~cc ~v ~ 3ffi e a.rr~ 88 ~-9~ 9 a. ~ l (~ ~ am i/~2 fll~c- • - 5"~ ~ 7. •'~~.~ 8. - ~ ~ ~~~CS~~ ~ -~ 10. ~ ~ti ~ f,,, 1 ~ T~~ ~ . 2 7`U 1~ ~ ~ L~C~V 1~~- B~~-zU7C~ 13. ~ i re~E ~~ 5 .~'~ C r ca ~ 1,~ ~ ~7~ 15~/ s/' ~. ~ / ~~ ~ /,dLL c ~ -~~l 1 °~.5~ ~ .~ E~ c ~ - ~ 1 ~ i ~~ ~~ -`~ 5 19 ~ ~,~ ~ ~_ l ~ y -0 2s~ 1 2 .S ~- -l/ ~ t.1(LC 21.~~ ~ ~ f ~~ d .~X~- Oo ~~ y I J • ~ SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ' ddress hone # Si lure 1~ e 1 ~ S p ~ ~ " ~ 30 ~ ~ ltiJ 2. ~ ~ r~L ~ ~ `7 C~r~~ ~'~5.~~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ 3. ~ ~ ~~ / ~ 4. ~ ~ ~ ' ~ C ~ _ `~ ,~, .~ 7. ~ ~3S ~ ~r v~,~-c.,~ X87- x`18 ~f to ~ ~ ~o S. W ~8~~~5Z I1 (~ ~'~" .~1 1 S S < ~`~-,~c~ X38-7 -9 ~' I /~,l ,' 14. 5 5 . 8"~' ~ 3 3 15. ~~ Cc ~. !,f l • ~ 16. S- U L ' ~UZ L 6 , 17. "/10 S, t~K,~l a- ~c.~ Q O U ~~ 18~ ~1 Z~~ 19. oM- 1 .~® ' ~ q -~ t Z 20. ~ ~ ~` ~ ~- 21.p~' c--/~ ~3~~ /'~-rwx per. y~~- 3~Q}/ ~~- • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name Address Phnne # Rivnafi,rP 1. `~ ~ ~~ ~a ( 6~~-~7s CQ I 2. Oun. ~ ~~ U ~, ~k ~ 759 _ 3. ~ 1~Yt,~ . ~11,~11't~ ~~ l~lc-~`~YKL~.vL~ 8~ 8'!3 ?!~ 4~~~~ Y! r~~ ~ \ / i s. ~~c- ~e ~hcle ~o~ ~ CJa~~m~ St g~~- 963 ~ ~IZc~.~~J 6. ~ c~. r ao~ tines- S t . $ y ~~z.~ 7. i ~~5 ~~~fm~ ~f, [l ~ 9. ~ O ~ ~~`f(5 1 ` S ~ - -l ,u ~~~~~/ ' ~~~~ G'~~/~i ~ ~~~ ~f l ~- 12 ,~ s y' /~ 13 ~ ~/~~ ~ ~~ i ~ 7 . j t~ jS ~~s~l 14. / , u1..v~.~-- /G ~~ G.~~e. ~`~' nt a ~ 5'f' BQI~' ~ ?~a S~ G~ ~, 16. ~ ~~s~~ ~~~ 17 18.Chri Eo.,rr,ey 3 17e2 I'vs ref G,r. ~d~- / d Zo g -3g 21 YID u/ - ~.D =~1 ~ a - - U` • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print ~,---- ~. l~iuuc ucuess none ~ ~i 1 /~/ /~ ~ Ur.~S ~~~w ~~ - 2. ~n,P,e e, es 1oW n ~s 7- ~ 3 e n p y 4~ ~~ ; ~ 5: 7~~~~ s. ~ ~ e 33 ~ . ~ ~'4; - Z ~. l~~/ 'lv - ~ ~ ~'~i~ qQ~7 g. /~~/ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ g .~l -, lU. -- ~ ~ ~ . P~' ~ ~~ ~ ~. bps' ~ - L.~ g 11. ~ Clt ~ ~' ~. UJ ~ ~ ~ITC-'-~ r ~. ~ ~ 7 6 ~-~ ` ~~ air ~ ~~- YES ~~ ~ 12. ~ 13. ,, /~.~ ~. Il~~ 8 ~7 ' q3 k 3 i -- ls. ~ ~ 7 `7 ~~1 '~ - ~ 5 16. / ' ~' -~ S' y5~ 17. ~ ~~z.~~~~;1 ~'~~r--~6oi ls. ~~ ~ e i 303 G~.~n ct-c 1 g~- ~ o ~. r 19. ~~ ~ , f~.~ ~~''74f 21. ckl, ~ S- C,a,nva~b ~- ~~~ - a ~ ~ I ~.,~~- l • ~ • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ~AArjrPCC Phnnn f! Cim.~f,,.n /1 - ----- -- - vi auav 2. ~ ~ wE~ o a ~ ~ ~~o ~~ o~~BS~ 3 ~~ 3. _ `~- 4. i QCt2 /o L /~ (•UZ'.L7~ ,Q . ~~' OD 7-!J ~~a~ 6~~~ 1~s~1 ~5~ u~tiwc~~ Ci 2~ ao8 88'~-~S~ ~ ~ - ~~ ~ c G 9.l_r ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ o ~2. w~ C 3 ~ ~+/u/ar/~ ~ d ~ ~~~ ~ -y~1 1 ~~ ~ r ~ ~l 17. \ R I (~ I ~ ~~ l ~r ~o~~ rc , - o 19. D 0/~ ~ oo ,~OFs-S'fr7- O~ 21. ou77i/120 /Qo ~2~srcvd0~ ~ r7. 208 -~'~-693j ~ ~ --___a ~~ • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ~AriArecc PhnnP # C1011afilrn l.~ c 1 ~ ~'t' o c.~ f / Z d' L'r' 'flc1 c cs ~i{ c~~cQ `--`~'Z ~ 2. V O' Ll CcJ ~~~ 3. acuna»lbbr~ i a-~ vv , cr~~5~6(, ~ . 8 ~ ~- lsv7 a 6. l33 l~ ~c~ $2?7-~~S ~ ~ ~ ~ o s. 37 ~ ryes-r~.rooc~ ~ ~~ ~ 9 y ~ b ~a,~e. 9. rN ~ w. < rs~~rv 4~~s~~a ia~r ~3 t~1, el'2 ~ o 00~ -~~$ ~~. ` ~ G~ ~-~~ ~~-Sz3 r~ ~~~ i cr~vc.rE 1337 W . C~s'r"Inl oor~ ~ 88 8 ~~246 ~7osci~x~c- S i~- c ~«e f~r~ g$ $ ~( C~~~ ~ X31 ~., v ~ is. t~9 r ~~8~v~b ~ - ~i~n~~r4.. ~l-~yo .~GcJ, /~ Mrs- -1~~ 1 r,>71r~ ~~ -~a3~ ~ ~ 20 ~ G !Yln G~-- ~~?i-~p 21. i ~ (7 ~,- ~ • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ~ ddr s hone # l.~~a~e .~ss~ ~A~ 3~.~ ~ w ~L-~Ic C~~~k ~r ~~- ~ C~ s ~~ r ~ -- "2r~~ `'~ ~' z ~~~ ~~~/~~6 f ~x ~~°7-1 ~ l~ 5. ~--r _ ~ ~/ ~ 1 U ~ _/ ~P -~ ~~~~ "C~~~~~, spy-~~ r r- ,- y-~ c, _. 1 ~`/a 1 ~ 2/VI ~~Ati~~l2 ~7~/Z 9 ~ / 1 ' ~ ~v 8'8 - lz s 12. /An ti,1QY.7r~ )y£s~ ~J~ 1K6-An~R ~~, ~~ ~~3`Q 13. 14. 1S. ~ u dlA ~~J'2tj S9K ~f ~~~ (~~~~ 16L -~I~h is C«~k Iq~34 W M~.~( nsru ~ ~-~3c~2, C',p~ 17. 7' ~ e ~' al~Ser ~i O~ - „~~' ~ 18 L ~- 19. Z -~ ~~~ zo. , ~, S y7 ~- ~ s© UU SAY NO TO SPORTS BARt We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name 'AcirirPCC Phnne ~! C10Tafilrr+ - //-- 1.1~~~ ~ ~1~~1/1 -pl-~---- -1U/'J W' (' ~ J ~' ---Q--- ~ ~, U~7' ~~.1~ ~~ -- --- - - 6 n n ~ mr~. ~~ D ~. i<c„-F K~ ~ [bze cam. KiMVLA Q,~~- S`7~~ 9. , a~~ 5 .~~- ~~~ - zS~ 11. ~~ I/~'• ~GiYlr~ ' ~'Z ~' 12. ~'~~ ~- g gg~ ~~ a 13. F-'YLVLCt `:~ ~~~ l ~l~I ~ C~µ~ ~$~ - ~3~0 ~-~ 1 . II~~ ~ . K ~(~d.~a~s . 15. rTe ~.~ Qr c C~ ~ ~'~~. - C ~~ ~ 18. f~'b/-U ~~e¢4 PI'S 3 w . ~li~~ s i ~d `/~~oG9 ~.c~ p u 19 c g+-/ - ~D i I ~.~z.G_~ t Zo. '~ ~. ~t ~ , ~ . ,~ g ~l ~ 80 i i vV-__Vvv • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BARt We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name `AririrPCC Dl,nnn ~! C;m,ot„rn 1. t ~ ~~1 ~~ (~3 1 ~ B'~~" IS ~• ~ W 2. ~ ~ ~3C~ ~, 1.~~-~s~, ll~ rr~- ~~y- ls~~ 4. ~ ~~~~ ~~Z ~ C~ ~`r`•r~g'~ Ir~ (~U -" v 03 w - ~ ~a ~~ ~ { A 9 ~, r~~ (V/~J 11// / Vf ~^ //u~/ ///J '~ V / 1 D~~UJ - (`oVjSVILL ~~ . ~'~J`6'd27~7 1 ` ~2.. A.y-EC.~' ~ Ui g~ 1- ~ 8 12. c 93 ~o -s ~~1~-1~9 ~ 13sf~ r l~~ i ~~ 15.f~~i~L~LIRASQ~!'' 9~J ~. LD ~SU~II-2- C--~ ~5~~~ J~`~I.S L v' 18. CS ~ ~- ~~'1 /"i n ~ L' ~ 19..E O~ CCl6 ~4~.~ G ~Q ( (~ • ~ i3 V ~L ~~ ~' ' ~`) g~ 2 o ts~r o~D ~~-ao 21 G ~~i • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print .,___ ~ fly u o7 ~ ~ ?„~ ~ l ~~ S~ .4 ~ ~ - ~ .~d ~vJ T 1 CTn1 l ~ `-, I . ~-~t ~~ ~ ~o gh5 g _ q I ~ L~\ ~" ~~~1 ~ i is U~~~~ ~~~ S r~'c K ~ / 8f~fc - ~y~~ ~ tr ~ _ ~ irc~,co,_ ttGcc~~ lhS~t v~~'~ae~, ~3~7-q' 7~u~U~ io • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ` ddress hone # Si cure 1 r ~ 01S -`l_ . 2. aL~,v~ ens ~n~~ w . ~ kea~.~ S~ ~~~- -lR 1 "~ 3. ~'F~X 8"~? ` ~ ~~orlJ f ~• ~~ 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name 'AAArPCC D1.....e ~ ~: - ---/~ ll AV Tf , - W c 3. --. 4. I r I s ~ mot. ~.. ~'- Sq 4~ T 6. \ ~ri ~~~ ~~h ~ ~ ~~~ ' bs S~, 7. 9 - u~t/~- ~' 7 ~ - lo. ~~P , 11. r elCc~ s 3 ? 3 S~. u~ ~ '~'~' A Y~ . n1ER/J~/m- ~~~ - b 3 8I 12~J Mc~~h/~ ~ ~ ~(~ ~ ~J /~''~PL ~~f~ 'f3 J '1 ~ 5`C/ ~ ~' v 16. ' 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Namn 'AeiArnec nt.___ ~ n_ - I ~' ~ ,j u uc a ~ 2 .s ~- r , as£~ - [c ~ ' ~ ` ~ ,, 6. -~ (~/ 9. h`i. k GL sv ~j l0 3 ~ L r+., f. ~ ~ a r /1 ~.. ~ 7_ ~/ y' 6 1 . ~/y'1 k~ 5 -C7 v 12. v ~~ -~ ~ 14 ~ Co (o ~ ~ l Juo Pa Z 15. ~ 7 / j. H6 7 - 2. y 95 16. ~ `` ~ k 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. ti • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print -000 ~ SKI -5l 1 ~ - • `7 SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name 'OrliirPCe AhnnP !! Qian l~h i r 1 e ~~Y~YI _ ~v_r.. ~ P ~, « ~ ~ CUcvn ~ r•v ~ ''~- U r ~G~ lti~~~ !' g~ _ - ~ a ~ .z.~--.-~- 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. ~ ~ SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print ivaine access on e ~ ~ ~i n 1. ~a ~ goy-- / T 3 ~f t~ ~ - ~/ ~ i ZS 6'~' ~ ~ 7'-/ t 5: Z ~ll~ - 6 rS 7 ~ c--.~~ ., a 7. - u~. 3~ 5 . e~ .~ ~ 88~ -~ 8" ~o L~ 1, ~ 9. e ~ 1 - ?~ 11.I'to~.~ .v l3 ss S. /~~d~ ~,L ~J~3 ~ 3 12. 13. i5 ~ ~' ~ ~ r i ~~nn ( (f Q 7 15V ~ nce ~a.rv~ l ~ ~s (~tJ . ~,•,~~ ~S c~7~ bSe~ 16 ~ -~a.1- 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. i .. • • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ~AririrPCC Dt,.,..e ~! C:......« -- ~ ~ a~V R IJl 1(iLYlb 2. o w ~ I c.`1~~2 ~ -~ 9~6 3. ra. '~rourn Imo W ~ ~ri-Fui,~ ~`~i-~ 5~~-- ~R6 7 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name `Arlr~rPCC PhnnP ~t .C10TahlrP 2. v'ZO ~, d CAD ~ ~~ - ~ ~L~~ 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name Address Phone # C;onat„rn 1. a arl ~o(~a~riv 33'7 ~- {CiI~/' gS'7-~ 3 3 2. ~ 1 $ - ~ 4. ' J ( b QS~t ~ g - to 4 ~b ~.UZ 6 /off W,~ P~S~ecR~llL' ~~~--~~~~' ~~ r n ~, I ~t~66 w~CcCS~w~ ~v. ~l-~~oZ ~ ~, . 1 J W ~ - b~ ^' ll.~f k~~/ ~ !'~ ~~ ~SY~I~O ~2~ ~~~ ~33~ 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ddress hone # Si 1. ~ _r 3. ` 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. -~ • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name Address PhnnP dE C; 1. ~~crt n.e. (~~ b 3~ N . c~ak. (X~ i~~r~ d.r`u-r, 8X ~-s'1 ~ -K.~~ 2. ~~+.e. i v~- o ~ '~ - 3. ~g - ~~.. ; h 4. ~, ~ _ ~ ` s. ~ ) I - ~i Cr• ~C. ~~el ~ 4~ g~~2~ ~- - 6.~/1QunC P~f~ 'on 3~Qs ~• m C /''( , b~7 ~ ~O$3 8 ~ l aw ~ ' S° 2 W ~ CIS Ciee/< r~~0,~ ~ 4~3`7.3~ G 7 ~~.~_ f 9 (7 ~ , 10. ~ P -~' 11 Y ' Gi. d.u~ V1J - r ~l ~ ~~~ -s~ ?~ 12. r 13. 14. 15. 16. " ~ .a„ 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. '~ SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ddress hone # Si lure 1. ~ !% R ~ > 7 ~ F~ col , ~ .r ~ ~ ~~fi 2. r ~^ ~~ ~ ~ a3 3 / o ' ~~ ~v~ 4. ~ ~' ZLv' ~ ~ ~~7 ~~'' y3 ~ l ~~~~ ~I ~'~~ ~~ ~ ~G~ ~ ~ e =,~Tn ~fSS` Gt/ 611 ~ ~ u vii S~ M~~ r o4 ~ ~'~~~ 7D Z 7. ;~. ,`~ ~o ~ / ~`'8~'~ 1n~ . wz .,~ v~. ~ R ~ chi-<. $$ ~ - ~ ~ :i-- ~ ~ ~~ ~ . ~ , y ~. ~ ~ ~~z<J d ,~ . ., ~ ~' ~ ~, , 11. ~, ~ciN' ~~~~~C v~i:~~s~Tl~. ~Fr~~, .-, ~- `"~7C=~y 12 ' ~~ ~;,, ~~r, - ~ t ~g -~ ~ ~u~l. ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~o~ ~ ~ ~~-,~~ -~ 13. cam/ ~ C,C~~ ~~~ ~~ ~ ~ ^ ~ ~b~~'~ 14. GecQ_ S 1 ~ ~ P..f . 8' 8' k -3 76 SL ~~. 15 ~~~ ~° ~ 16.E ~ ~ ~~. J~IC=' ~ C~+~ , ~ c%~~.~. ~~~G~' G~1~~ ~`-1 17 ~ 14'1 G7i2. .~ '~ ~~~ . " ' ,~ -y 19. ~ 20. 21. SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print ~u- 501 S . ~ ~~~ ~g~ D X20 ~ t ~ ~ ~u s. 5~ /.ia -, SiS~ n/ F~~s--c~ / ~ ~' p o ai>f / ~ -- ~~ J ~ ~ /~ , • SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ddress hone # Si ~-wc 2.I~Ki'~~ e. 3~. P fsq 7 -~ srs 3. s ~ $ - 55 , 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. J SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name ~AA~irwcc Ahnns+ f! Cion~h^rn 1. P f % Pr?~--1~' I ~a~C~l (,(:.. Yr ~ ~' L ctrl ~a ~' ' b' 1.[' 33 ~' C ~ t ~4 ~Y~TU~ C~~ 1 ~~-' l~~ ~ 4?. ~~~mr ~fYl~..~i~~c~~ ~` ~-~~ a l '~~~ ~ ~~ l3iv w. K~rn~a. n~~r,dtdn 5. - 6. ~ - ~ < s. ~ ~t, v •~. ~9~ 7 ~ 7 ~! y 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. • ~ SAY NO TO SPORTS BAR! We the undersigned do not want a Sport Bar built at the SW 1/4 of the SW1/4 of Section 12, T.3N., R.1 W., B.M., Ada County, Idaho, and which property is generally located at the comer east of Linder Road and North of Franklin Road. Please print Name 'A Ari.rcc D},nnn ~f c~..R,.~.b - ---- C©T1~ ~licrn~h - /Z$~1 ~' /-ash Its p~• ~¢r1ol~~ a.vaw ,. ~$~ //D~ a a~aa c 2f~~ te. ~.rf-w~a _ / Z ~/ S l~tl.. !t c P1 • h2t rr al,' ~ ~~'l/4~ 3. 7~(0 !9~ 4 Z ~~ ~6~ 6. 5 ~ ee ~ g~'7-~3~r3 7. ~ F ~ 1a ~ W. IC--M ~ g. z . ~K~ f 8 g~ -~z~ a s Q ,' d , ,~ ~ ~ ~ o. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.